Rookie Class Predictions, Award Winners, and Superlatives
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Rookie Class Predictions, Award Winners, and Superlatives” inside PodZeus.
In this special 'Dan Comer joint' episode of The McShay Show, hosts Mitch and McShay dive deep into 2026 NFL rookie class predictions, awarding fictional honors to highlight standout players and fits across the draft. They explore a range of categories—from 'The Better as a Pro Award' to 'The Missing Peace Award'—with standout picks including Marlon Klein (Texans), Keldrick Falk (Titans), and Eli Stowers (Eagles). The duo also spotlight under-the-radar players overcoming red flags, such as Ty Simpson and Spencer Fano, and predict breakout performances from late-round gems like Keontae Scott and Jonah Coleman. The episode culminates in their projections for Offensive and Defensive Rookie of the Year, with Carnell Tate and Caleb Downs emerging as top contenders. Throughout, the hosts blend humor, deep scouting insight, and playful banter, while promoting the McShay Report and upcoming mailbag show for subscribers.
Marlon Klein (Texans) is projected to thrive in Nick Caley’s tight end-friendly offense, potentially outperforming his college production.
Keldrick Falk (Titans) is a versatile edge rusher whose fit with Robert Sala’s defensive scheme could unlock elite pass-rushing potential.
Eli Stowers (Eagles) is seen as a game-changing weapon due to Sean McVay’s offensive system and his unique skill set beyond traditional tight end roles.
Caleb Downs (Cowboys) is predicted to be a transformative force in Dallas’ revamped defense, despite being drafted outside the top five.
Ty Simpson (Rams) is viewed as the ideal fit for Sean McVay’s complex offense, overcoming his lack of experience through elite processing ability.
…and 2 more takeaways available in PodZeus
Introducing the Dan Comer Joint & Draft Countdown
The episode opens with Mitch welcoming Dan Comer as the producer, marking a new era for The McShay Show. They tease the upcoming 2026 NFL draft, promote the McShay Report and new website, and preview Monday’s Fantasy Football Expectations show.
The Better as a Pro Award: Marlon Klein & Keldrick Falk
“I think he's going to be that three. He's going to be that four-eye. He's going to be a five. You're going to see him moving all around, around offensive tackles and guards.”
The Missing Peace Award: Eli Stowers & Akeem Mesidor
“This and what looked like, oh, I don't like the fact that they lost their third edge rusher and pass rush specialist. This is actually an upgrade.”
The Outlier Didn't Matter Award: Ty Simpson & Spencer Fano
“He has a different kind of brain. And he can process and handle information in a different way, and he can handle the McVay offense.”
The How Did He Fall Award: Keontae Scott & Jonah Coleman
“He's like a bowling ball, but I told you with like a joystick attached. You know? One fumble lost in four years.”
“I think we're going to watch a Dallas defense go from among the worst in the last two years in the NFL to maybe a top 10 unit this year.”
“I think he's going to be that three. He's going to be that four-eye. He's going to be a five. You're going to see him moving all around, around offensive tackles and guards.”
“I could see him in Dallas, the star. Yeah. Tension every week. He's got a... two or three highlight plays every week.”
Hosts
Mitch
person
McShay
person
Dan Comer
person
Keldrick Falk
person
Eli Stowers
person
Caleb Downs
person
Akeem Mesidor
person
Marlon Klein
person
Jeremiah Love
person
Spencer Fano
person
A Taylen Green Epiphany. Plus, Indiana and Jermod McCoy Pro Day Reactions.
The McShay Show • 1h 7m • 4/1/2026
Will Mendoza or Cousins Start? Plus, the Draft Outliers Confidence Index With Bain, Simpson, Lemon, and More.
The McShay Show • 53m • 4/3/2026
Our Top 150 Big Board Risers and Fallers. Plus, Don’t Be Surprised If …
The McShay Show • 1h 6m • 4/6/2026
Emptying the NFL Draft Notebook With Albert Breer
The McShay Show • 1h 27m • 4/8/2026
First-Round Pivot Points, Jordyn Tyson Stock Watch, and the McShay Mailbag
The McShay Show • 1h 15m • 4/10/2026
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Rookie Class Predictions, Award Winners, and Superlatives” inside PodZeus.
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime