Will Mendoza or Cousins Start? Plus, the Draft Outliers Confidence Index With Bain, Simpson, Lemon, and More.
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Will Mendoza or Cousins Start? Plus, the Draft Outliers Confidence Index With Bain, Simpson, Lemon, and More.” inside PodZeus.
The McShay Show dives deep into the 2026 NFL Draft landscape, focusing on the Raiders' strategic signing of Kirk Cousins to serve as a mentor and backup for top overall pick Fernando Mendoza. The hosts debate the wisdom of having a veteran quarterback absorb the pressure of a rookie starter, drawing parallels to Tom Brady’s long-standing advocacy for quarterback development. They highlight the benefits of Mendoza learning from a proven pro like Cousins, emphasizing the value of watching a 'consummate pro' prepare and perform. The episode also explores draft outliers—players who defy conventional size or physical metrics but show elite production—examining Ty Simpson, Ruben Bain, Makai Lemon, D'Angelo Ponds, and Spencer Fano. Each player is assessed through a confidence index (1–10) based on their draft value, physical limitations, and historical precedent. The hosts acknowledge the emotional pull of falling in love with players during deep tape study, but stress the importance of balancing passion with realism. The show closes with a preview of the upcoming live draft coverage from LA, hosted by The Ringer and powered by FanDuel.
Kirk Cousins’ one-year, $20M deal with the Raiders is designed to protect rookie QB Fernando Mendoza by removing the pressure of being a day-one starter.
Mendoza benefits from watching a 'consummate pro' like Cousins prepare and perform, accelerating his development through observation.
Outlier players like Ruben Bain and Makai Lemon defy traditional size norms but show elite production—confidence in their NFL success depends on overcoming historical skepticism.
The draft process is now overwhelmed with data, analytics, and social media content, making it harder for scouts to separate signal from noise.
Teams like Arizona and the Jets are positioning for 2027 by potentially trading back or saving picks, signaling long-term planning beyond the 2026 draft.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
Kirk Cousins’ Role in the Raiders’ QB Strategy
“If it's four games, if it's eight games, if it's 12 games, whatever it is, I think Mendoza benefits greatly from this man.”
The Outlier Dilemma: Falling in Love with Players
The hosts reflect on the emotional bond formed during deep tape study and how it can cloud judgment. They use the metaphor of dating to explain why evaluators fall in love with players, even when physical outliers like Ruben Bain or Makai Lemon defy traditional norms.
Confidence Index: Evaluating Draft Outliers
“I don't buy it. I do not buy it. All right, I don't buy it.”
The Draft’s Long-Term Strategy: 2027 Planning
The discussion shifts to teams like the Jets and Arizona Cardinals, who may be trading back to preserve picks for 2027. The hosts explore the idea of building for the future, including the potential for Ty Simpson to be a 2027 cornerstone.
The Evolution of Scouting in the Age of Data
The hosts reflect on how modern scouting has shifted from physical evaluation to psychological and analytical assessment. With access to endless data, tape, and AI tools, scouts now spend more time evaluating the 'human being' behind the player.
“I don't buy it. I do not buy it. All right, I don't buy it.”
“The league has changed. Scouts used to spend 70, 80% of their time evaluating players and trying to unearth small school guys... Now they spend 70% trying to figure out who the human being is.”
“If it's four games, if it's eight games, if it's 12 games, whatever it is, I think Mendoza benefits greatly from this man.”
Hosts
kirk cousins
person
ty simpson
person
fernando mendoza
person
ruben bain
person
jeremiah love
person
raiders
organization
makai lemon
person
tom brady
person
d'angelo ponds
person
the ringer
organization
A Taylen Green Epiphany. Plus, Indiana and Jermod McCoy Pro Day Reactions.
The McShay Show • 1h 7m • 4/1/2026
Our Top 150 Big Board Risers and Fallers. Plus, Don’t Be Surprised If …
The McShay Show • 1h 6m • 4/6/2026
Emptying the NFL Draft Notebook With Albert Breer
The McShay Show • 1h 27m • 4/8/2026
First-Round Pivot Points, Jordyn Tyson Stock Watch, and the McShay Mailbag
The McShay Show • 1h 15m • 4/10/2026
Our Top-200 Big Board: Stacking Safeties, Second-Tier Edges, and WR Intel
The McShay Show • 1h 15m • 4/13/2026
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Will Mendoza or Cousins Start? Plus, the Draft Outliers Confidence Index With Bain, Simpson, Lemon, and More.” inside PodZeus.
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime