Why are there so many Marys in the Bible?

Q with Tom Power18mApril 22, 2026

Get the full intelligence

Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Why are there so many Marys in the Bible?” inside PodZeus.

AI-Generated Summary

In this episode of Q with Tom Power, playwright Erin Shields discusses her new play, *Mary, Mary, Mary, Mary*, which centers on four women in the Bible named Mary—Mary, the mother of Jesus, Mary Magdalene, Mary the mother of James and John, and Mary of Bethany. Shields explores the historical and cultural significance of these women, questioning why so many are named Mary and how their individual stories have been overshadowed by collective narratives. She reflects on the marginalization of women in religious texts, the mythologizing of Mary Magdalene as a prostitute (a misrepresentation stemming from a 6th-century sermon), and the emotional weight of motherhood in the crucifixion narrative. The play also delves into themes of identity, agency, and the untold lives of women in foundational stories, drawing parallels to her other works like *Medusa* and *Paradise Lost*. Shields emphasizes the importance of reimagining forgotten voices, especially women and non-binary figures, to challenge dominant narratives and invite empathy across gender lines.

Key Takeaways
1

There are multiple women named Mary in the Bible, and their individual stories have often been erased or conflated.

2

Mary Magdalene was wrongly labeled a prostitute due to a 591 sermon by Pope Gregory, not from biblical text.

3

Women in early Christianity played crucial, often unseen roles—like preparing the Last Supper—despite being excluded from formal recognition.

4

Reimagining historical figures like Mary and Medusa allows audiences to confront emotional depth, trauma, and agency in marginalized voices.

5

Shields' work invites both religious and secular audiences to engage with sacred stories through a contemporary, human-centered lens.

Chapters
0:00
2 min

Introduction to the Episode and Guest

Tom Power introduces the episode and welcomes playwright Erin Shields, highlighting her recent surge of new plays and her latest work, *Mary, Mary, Mary, Mary*, which explores the lives of four women named Mary in the Bible.

2:00
3 min

The Mystery of Multiple Marys

I was like, why don't I read the Bible? Because, you know, everything had been canceled with lots of time. And just Mary kept coming up.

Highlight
5:00
4 min

The Four Marys and Their Roles

I really thought about who is this collective of Marys? And as they move toward the end of this story, to the crucifixion and the resurrection, what becomes of them then when they no longer have to be a group?

Highlight
9:00
5 min

Reclaiming Mary Magdalene and Challenging Myths

In 591, Pope Gregory made a sermon where he conflated the sinful woman... with Mary Magdalene. And he thought the sinful woman was definitely a prostitute, and therefore Mary Magdalene was also a prostitute.

Highlight
14:00
5 min

Humanizing the Mother of Jesus and the Power of Storytelling

I can't imagine anything worse than one of them dying. More of my conversation with Aaron Shields coming up in just a moment.

Highlight
High-Impact Quotes
In 591, Pope Gregory made a sermon where he conflated the sinful woman... with Mary Magdalene. And he thought the sinful woman was definitely a prostitute, and therefore Mary Magdalene was also a prostitute.
Erin Shields7:26
Viral: 85.0
I can't imagine anything worse than one of them dying.
Erin Shields10:17
Viral: 80.0
I really thought about who is this collective of Marys? And as they move toward the end of this story, to the crucifixion and the resurrection, what becomes of them then when they no longer have to be a group?
Erin Shields5:00
Viral: 78.0
Speakers

Host

Tom Power

Guest

Erin Shields
Topics Discussed
Mary Magdalene's Misrepresentation95%Feminist Storytelling92%Women in the Bible90%Reimagining Religious Narratives88%Motherhood and Grief in Religious Context87%Collective Identity vs Individuality85%Myth vs History in Christianity80%Greek Mythology and Modern Adaptation75%
People & Brands

Erin Shields

person

12xPositive

Mary Magdalene

person

10xPositive

Mary, mother of Jesus

person

8xPositive

Tom Power

person

6xPositive

Medusa

person

5xPositive

Paradise Lost

media

2xPositive

Soulpepper Theatre

organization

2xPositive

Pope Gregory

person

2xNegative

Caitlin

person

2xNeutral

Athena

person

2xNegative

Get the full intelligence

Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Why are there so many Marys in the Bible?” inside PodZeus.

Start discovering podcast insights today

Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.

No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime