Val McDermid 2007-10-15

Poisoned Pen Podcast58mApril 9, 2026

Get the full intelligence

Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Val McDermid 2007-10-15” inside PodZeus.

AI-Generated Summary

In this engaging episode of the Poisoned Pen Podcast, host Barbara Peters interviews acclaimed crime writer Val McDermid, discussing her award-winning debut novel *The Mermaid Singing* and her evolution as a writer. McDermid recounts the surreal moment the story came to her while driving on the motorway, describing it as a 'gift from the gods' that demanded immediate transcription. She delves into the novel’s innovative dual narrative—combining a police investigation with the killer’s own diary—highlighting her intention to subvert the typical serial killer thriller by making it a true whodunit. The conversation explores her meticulous research, including a pivotal visit to a museum of medieval torture in San Gimignano, Italy, which provided chilling inspiration. McDermid reflects on the psychological toll of writing from the killer’s perspective and contrasts her own squeamishness with the dark imagination required for such work. She also discusses her journey from Scottish state school to Oxford, her early career in journalism, and how those experiences shaped her crime fiction, including the creation of journalist protagonist Lindsay Gordon and private investigator Kate Brannigan. The episode concludes with a thoughtful exchange on her role as a book reviewer, where she balances honesty with empathy, especially when reviewing friends’ work, and celebrates the growing cross-cultural exchange between British and American crime fiction.

Key Takeaways
1

Write the most emotionally difficult sections (like a killer's diary) in one intense burst to maintain voice consistency and reduce psychological strain.

2

Use real-world research—like visiting a museum of medieval torture—to ground dark fiction in authentic detail and avoid gratuitous violence.

3

The best crime fiction balances graphic content with narrative function, avoiding titillation and treating victims as real people.

4

A writer’s personal history—geography, class, education—can deeply inform their voice and thematic choices.

5

Journalism teaches discipline: the ability to write 1,500 words daily, regardless of mood, is a crucial skill for professional writers.

…and 2 more takeaways available in PodZeus

Chapters
0:00
10 min

Introduction and the Birth of The Mermaid Singing

It was so vivid. I thought, I have to write this down right now or I'm going to lose it.

Highlight
10:00
10 min

The Dual Narrative: Whodunit Meets Serial Killer Thriller

It's kind of a serial killer thriller that's also a whodunit.

Highlight
20:00
10 min

Research and Inspiration: The Museum of Medieval Torture

The objects themselves were often very, very beautiful... You look at them and if you didn't know what they were, you would say, what a marvelous piece of engineering.

Highlight
30:00
10 min

Writing from the Killer’s Perspective: Psychological Toll

McDermid discusses the emotional difficulty of writing the killer’s diary, describing it as a 'very uncomfortable place to be.' She wrote it in a single, intense burst to maintain consistency and protect her mental state.

40:00
10 min

From Scotland to Oxford: A Journey of Escape and Identity

McDermid shares her upbringing in Kirkcaldy, Scotland, and her determination to escape the insular culture of Fife by attending Oxford. She recounts being rejected by her school but persisting to gain admission at age 16.

High-Impact Quotes
Because you're a practitioner as well, I have to take what you say seriously.
Ian Rankin53:30
Viral: 90.0
It was so vivid. I thought, I have to write this down right now or I'm going to lose it.
Val McDermid2:21
Viral: 85.0
I can always write 1,500 words a day. It wasn't always going to be 1,500 wonderful words, but once you had 1,500 words down on paper, somebody could go and make them better.
Val McDermid33:30
Viral: 82.0
Speakers

Host

Barbara Peters

Guest

Val McDermid
Topics Discussed
Dual Narrative Structure in Crime Fiction90%Research and Authenticity in Crime Writing88%Cross-Cultural Exchange in Crime Fiction86%Psychological Realism in Serial Killer Fiction85%Ethics of Book Reviewing84%Female Private Investigators in Real Life and Fiction82%The Role of Journalism in Fiction Writing80%Author Identity and Regional Roots78%
People & Brands

Val McDermid

person

15xPositive

The Mermaid Singing

book

12xPositive

Barbara Peters

person

10xPositive

The Poisoned Pen

organization

8xPositive

Tony Hill

person

8xPositive

Carol Jordan

person

7xPositive

Lindsay Gordon

person

6xPositive

Oxford

place

6xPositive

St Hilda's College

organization

5xPositive

Kate Brannigan

person

5xPositive

Get the full intelligence

Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Val McDermid 2007-10-15” inside PodZeus.

Start discovering podcast insights today

Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.

No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime