RED FLAG: Will Dallas Cowboys PASS On Jermod McCoy Despite STRONG Pro Day Performance?

The Locked On Cowboys podcast dives into the rising draft buzz around Jermaud McCoy, a Tennessee cornerback whose strong pro day performance—featuring a 4.40-second 40-yard dash, 37.5-inch vertical, and 10-7 broad jump—has reignited interest in his stock. Despite the impressive physical numbers, hosts Marcus Mosher and Landon McCool express deep skepticism about McCoy’s long-term viability due to a 14-month recovery from ACL surgery, missed opportunities at the NFL Combine and Senior Bowl, and a lack of comprehensive on-field testing. They question why he skipped so many key events and remain uncertain about his true health, especially given the timeline of his recovery. While acknowledging his potential upside and elite tape from his sophomore year, both hosts lean toward caution, suggesting the Cowboys should pass on him at pick 12 due to the high injury risk and lack of medical clarity. They speculate he could fall between picks 13 and 19, but warn that even if available, the risk may outweigh the reward for a team needing instant contributors. The episode also promotes the Everydayer Club for ad-free listening and real-time discussion in a private Discord, while highlighting Robin Hood’s prediction markets as a tool for fans to engage with sports in a dynamic, live way. The hosts remain cautiously optimistic about the draft class but emphasize that the Cowboys must prioritize health and reliability over upside when making high-stakes picks.