BEST CASE: Ranking The TOP NFL Draft Outcomes For The Dallas Cowboys | Will Downs Fall To No. 12?

Locked On Cowboys - Daily Podcast On The Dallas Cowboys27mApril 2, 2026

Get the full intelligence

Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “BEST CASE: Ranking The TOP NFL Draft Outcomes For The Dallas Cowboys | Will Downs Fall To No. 12?” inside PodZeus.

AI-Generated Summary

In this episode of Locked On Cowboys, hosts Marcus Mosher and Landon McCool dive into the best-case scenarios for the Dallas Cowboys in the 2026 NFL Draft, focusing on their first-round selection at pick 12. They explore the ideal outcome: a top-tier defensive player—Mansoor Delane, Sonny Styles, or Caleb Downs—falling to the Cowboys due to a crowded offensive player pool in the top 11. The hosts emphasize that with at least five offensive players likely to be selected before pick 12, defensive talent could be undervalued and available. They also discuss strategic trade scenarios, including trading up to pick 6 for Arvel Reese or making a multi-pick deal with Arizona to land Reese at #3, and trading down to gain additional value and depth. The episode highlights the importance of drafting foundational, high-value players on cheap contracts rather than reaching for offensive linemen or flawed defensive prospects. The hosts express strong skepticism about drafting offensive tackles like Spencer Fano or Francis Mauanoa at 12, calling it a misallocation of resources, and warn against drafting players like C.J. Allen or Mesador due to injury risks and lack of long-term upside. The overarching theme is maximizing value through smart draft strategy, with Miles Garrett being the ultimate 'best case' if available via trade.

Key Takeaways
1

The best-case scenario is one of three elite defensive players—Mansoor Delane, Sonny Styles, or Caleb Downs—falling to pick 12 due to a crowded offensive player pool in the top 11.

2

Trading up to pick 6 for Arvel Reese (if available) or trading with Arizona for the #3 pick could secure a proven pass rusher while gaining additional value.

3

Trading down from 12 to 21 (e.g., to Pittsburgh) could yield valuable second-round picks and immediate contributors like Nick Herbig or Alex Highsmith.

4

Avoid drafting offensive linemen at 12—especially Spencer Fano or Francis Mauanoa—due to misallocation of resources and the team’s current depth at tackle.

5

Do not reach on flawed defensive players like C.J. Allen or Mesador; prioritize high-upside, low-risk, foundational players on cheap contracts.

…and 2 more takeaways available in PodZeus

Chapters
0:00
2 min

Welcome & Episode Overview

Introduction to the Locked On Cowboys podcast and the Everydayer Club ad-free subscription. Hosts set the stage for discussing the best-case draft outcomes for the Cowboys at pick 12.

1:40
5 min

Best Case: Elite Defensive Talent Falls to 12

If the Cowboys get one of these guys at 12 without having to trade up or do any maneuvering, sign me up. That is an A++ draft for me.

Highlight
6:40
5 min

Trade-Up Scenarios: Targeting Reese or Top Talent

It really, really hits two weaknesses extremely hard. You get a proven pass rusher who comes in, can serve as the number one, has worked in this defense before.

Highlight
11:40
7 min

Trade-Down & Creative Draft Strategy

You get a player that can come in and contribute right away, and you check off one of your boxes right away. So I love these kind of more creative trade ideas.

Highlight
18:20
9 min

Worst Case Scenarios & Final Thoughts

If the Cowboys stayed at 12 and they went out and picked like Francis Malinoa or Spencer Fano, I just... I think I would be shocked before I would get really upset.

Highlight
High-Impact Quotes
Miles Garrett! That is number one. Yes. That is it for today's show.
Landon McCool27:01
Viral: 95.0
Do not draft an offensive lineman, please. Please. Miles Garrett!
Marcus Mosher26:56
Viral: 92.0
If the Cowboys stayed at 12 and they went out and picked like Francis Malinoa or Spencer Fano, I just... I think I would be shocked before I would get really upset.
Marcus Mosher21:11
Viral: 90.0
Speakers

Hosts

Marcus MosherLandon McCool
Topics Discussed
NFL Draft Strategy95%Dallas Cowboys Draft Outlook90%Trade-Up and Trade-Down Scenarios88%Defensive Talent Evaluation85%Offensive Line Draft Risks80%Player Value and Positional Need78%Draft Board Dynamics75%Team Building Through Draft70%
People & Brands

Dallas Cowboys

other

35xPositive

Landon McCool

person

14xPositive

Marcus Mosher

person

12xNeutral

Mansoor Delane

person

8xPositive

Sonny Styles

person

7xPositive

Caleb Downs

person

6xPositive

Arizona Cardinals

other

6xNeutral

Arvel Reese

person

5xPositive

Spencer Fano

person

5xNegative

Pittsburgh Steelers

other

4xNeutral

Get the full intelligence

Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “BEST CASE: Ranking The TOP NFL Draft Outcomes For The Dallas Cowboys | Will Downs Fall To No. 12?” inside PodZeus.

Start discovering podcast insights today

Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.

No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime