New York City_s BERMUDA Triangle Is Real _ Terrifying
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “New York City_s BERMUDA Triangle Is Real _ Terrifying” inside PodZeus.
This episode of Everytown explores a growing mystery surrounding the sudden appearance of eight bodies in Jamaica Bay, New York City, within a single year—far exceeding historical norms. The cases, involving victims ranging from a celebrated Irish filmmaker to unidentified individuals, have sparked speculation about whether this is a series of tragic accidents, suicides, or something more sinister, such as a potential serial killer or dumping ground. While authorities have not confirmed foul play in any case, the lack of clear explanations, missing security footage, and the bay’s complex geography have fueled theories likening the area to New York’s 'Bermuda Triangle.' The episode draws parallels to the long-unresolved Gilgo Beach serial killer case, highlighting how even with modern forensics, such crimes can remain hidden for years. Experts weigh in on victimology, environmental factors, and the challenges of search operations in the bay’s murky, vegetated waters, while community leaders demand greater transparency and action from law enforcement.
Eight bodies found in Jamaica Bay within less than a year is statistically unprecedented and has raised alarm among locals and officials.
The lack of clear cause of death, missing security footage, and the bay's complex currents make investigations extremely difficult.
While some victims had known mental health struggles or were known to swim in the area, the pattern of disappearances suggests deeper systemic or criminal issues.
The Gilgo Beach serial killer case serves as a cautionary parallel, showing how bodies can be hidden for years despite extensive investigations.
Authorities have increased surveillance with drones and patrols, but results remain limited due to the bay’s challenging environment.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
The Rising Body Count in Jamaica Bay
“Eight bodies in less than one year is a heck of a lot to show up in one spot and way above the norm here.”
The Victims and Their Mysterious Disappearances
The episode details the cases of several victims, including filmmaker Ross McDonald, who vanished after leaving his Brooklyn apartment, and others found beheaded or unidentified. The lack of evidence and security footage fuels suspicion and public concern.
The Gilgo Beach Parallel: A Cautionary Tale
“The Gilgo Beach killings, even though much more open and shut than what's happening in Jamaica Bay, still had its share of problems.”
Environmental and Investigative Challenges
Experts explain how Jamaica Bay’s dense vegetation, shifting currents, and man-made alterations make search and recovery operations extremely difficult. The bay literally 'swallows the evidence,' complicating investigations.
Possible Explanations: Accident, Suicide, or Murder?
“The simple reality is that, as populations grow, especially in a condensed city like New York, the amount of people dying will also increase.”
“You never know, maybe your town will be next.”
“Eight bodies in less than one year is a heck of a lot to show up in one spot and way above the norm here.”
“The simple reality is that, as populations grow, especially in a condensed city like New York, the amount of people dying will also increase.”
Host
Jamaica Bay
place
New York City
place
Ross McDonald
person
Gilgo Beach
place
Rex Heuermann
person
NYPD
organization
Colin Marma
person
Dan Mundy Jr.
person
Queens Councilwoman Joan Areola
person
Joe Giacolone
person
When Cops Catch Killers Red Handed
TruRed CRIME • 32m • 4/12/2026
When Cops Weapons Fail
TruRed CRIME • 20m • 4/12/2026
When Cops Realize Their Partner Is A Killer
TruRed CRIME • 30m • 4/12/2026
When A Terrorist Doesn_t Realize He_s Being Recorded.
TruRed CRIME • 17m • 4/12/2026
When Murderers Record Their Kills
TruRed CRIME • 33m • 4/12/2026
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “New York City_s BERMUDA Triangle Is Real _ Terrifying” inside PodZeus.
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime