Episode 545: True Crime Time
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Episode 545: True Crime Time” inside PodZeus.
In this gripping episode of True Anon Truth Feed, host Drew Non and guest Rachel Corbett dive deep into the psychological and societal obsession with understanding violent criminals, using Corbett's own traumatic childhood connection to a murder-suicide as a springboard. Corbett, a features writer for New York Magazine, recounts how her childhood father figure, Scott Johnson, murdered his new girlfriend and himself—shattering her perception of safety and normalcy. This personal trauma fuels her exploration in her book, *The Monsters We Make*, which dissects the myth of criminal profiling, from phrenology to modern predictive policing. The conversation exposes the dangerous illusion of control we seek when trying to decode evil, revealing how institutions like the FBI weaponized pseudoscience through the 'mindhunter' myth, and how systems like predictive policing in Florida turned children into 'pre-criminals' through surveillance and harassment. The episode culminates in a chilling portrait of art dealer Andrew Crispo—a charming, sociopathic predator who manipulated, groomed, and orchestrated multiple murders through sadistic rituals, all while evading justice. Corbett’s investigative journalism reveals a world where power, wealth, and trauma converge, and where the line between predator and victim blurs, leaving listeners questioning whether we can ever truly know the monsters we create—or if we’re already one of them.
Understanding a killer’s mind is often a futile quest driven by our need for control, not truth.
Pseudoscientific profiling (from phrenology to predictive policing) has repeatedly failed but remains culturally dominant.
Grooming and psychological manipulation can turn vulnerable individuals into violent accomplices, as seen in Crispo’s manipulation of Bernard Leggeros.
Institutional systems—like the FBI’s 'mindhunter' narrative or predictive policing—often create the very monsters they claim to prevent.
The most dangerous 'monsters' are not always the obvious villains; they can be charismatic, wealthy, and legally untouchable.
The Illusion of Seeing Into Minds
The episode opens with a surreal meditation on perception, identity, and the absurdity of trying to 'walk in someone else's shoes'—a metaphor for the podcast's central theme: the dangerous fantasy of understanding evil.
Rachel Week: The Ritual of Obsession
The hosts introduce the annual 'Rachel Week' tradition, a satirical celebration of obsession with the name 'Rachel,' which evolves into a thematic container for the episode’s deeper exploration of psychological fixation and narrative control.
A Childhood Murder and the Birth of a Monster
“I became just super obsessed with trying to understand who this man was and who the boy was. I went back and met the boy and went back to the house and tried to piece together kind of like a profile of this man.”
The Myth of the Mindhunter: From Phrenology to MKUltra
“He would try to figure out how you could sort of destroy someone through humiliation. And then, in theory, he was going to build that back up, but it turns out he wasn't so interested in that part at the end.”
Predictive Policing and the Creation of Criminals
“He spent like several years of his teenage life in lockup for nothing. Jesus. Just in and out, but for these huge, you know, for 60 days or whatever it was at a time.”
“Crispo's like okay it's time, he's ready now. He has him kneel down, he's naked. He's handcuffed behind his back, and he's wearing that hood. And he says to Bernard, it's time. He's ready now.”
“He's like shitting in the hallway of some fucking dump ass apartment he has here even though he's got the crib in the Hamptons still and you look and you... No, the place in the Hamptons blew up actually mysteriously.”
“He spent like several years of his teenage life in lockup for nothing. Jesus. Just in and out, but for these huge, you know, for 60 days or whatever it was at a time.”
Host
Guest
Andrew Crispo
person
Drew Non
person
Rachel Corbett
person
Bernard Leggeros
person
Henry Murray
person
Scott Johnson
person
FBI
organization
Ted Kaczynski
person
The Monsters We Make
book
Roy Cohn
person
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Episode 545: True Crime Time” inside PodZeus.
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime
