TRADCAST EXPRESS 224: Fr. James Mawdsley and the Good Friday Genuflection Controversy
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “TRADCAST EXPRESS 224: Fr. James Mawdsley and the Good Friday Genuflection Controversy” inside PodZeus.
This episode of Tradcast Express examines the controversy surrounding Father James Maudsley's 2025 video 'Standing for Christ on Good Friday,' in which he urges Catholics to refuse to genuflect during the intercessory prayer for the conversion of the Jews on Good Friday. The host argues that Maudsley's position—advocating public resistance to a liturgical directive of Pope Pius XII—contradicts Catholic teaching on papal authority and liturgical obedience. While acknowledging that some traditionalists, including Sedevacantists, debate whether to use the 1955 revised Holy Week liturgy, the episode emphasizes that Maudsley’s call to rebel against a reigning pope’s liturgical decree is fundamentally flawed. The host traces the historical context of the genuflection exception, explains that Pope Pius XII’s 1955 change was a legitimate exercise of papal authority, and cites Church teaching from Mediator Dei, Quanta Cora, and others to affirm that no private individual may override papal liturgical decisions. The episode concludes that resisting a papally mandated liturgical action under the guise of tradition is not only illogical but potentially blasphemous, as it implies the Church herself is mocking Christ. The host calls for submission to the Pope as the ultimate guardian of the faith, not personal interpretation of tradition.
Papal authority over liturgical matters is supreme and binding; no individual may refuse to comply with a valid papal decree.
The 1955 change by Pope Pius XII to include a genuflection during the prayer for the Jews was a legitimate liturgical reform, not a corruption of tradition.
Refusing to genuflect in a papally mandated liturgy is not a form of spiritual resistance—it is a denial of ecclesial unity and obedience.
The Church’s liturgy is not a menu to pick and choose from; participation means assenting to the entire rite as a unified act of worship.
Tradition is not a substitute for papal authority; the Pope is the divinely appointed guardian of the deposit of faith.
Introduction to the Controversy
“If we cannot get the Holy Week liturgy right, it is like trying to redeem the world without Christ or with a different Christ, one invented by modernity. Absit.”
Who is Father Maudsley?
The host provides background on Maudsley: a British-Australian traditionalist priest ordained by Archbishop Guido Pozzo, holding a 'recognize and resist' theology that accepts modern popes but resists their teachings when deemed harmful to tradition.
The Liturgical Change and Its Context
“The church has no hesitation in offering up a prayer for the descendants of Jesus' executioners. But in doing so, she refrains from genuflecting. Because this mark of adoration was turned by the Jews into an insult against our Lord during the Passion.”
Theological and Doctrinal Rebuttal
“The sovereign pontiff alone enjoys the right to recognize and establish any practice touching the worship of God. No private person has any authority to regulate external practices of this kind...”
The Absurdity of Selective Participation
The episode argues that liturgical participation is holistic: one cannot pick and choose parts of the liturgy to accept or reject. Refusing to genuflect while attending a papally mandated liturgy is not resistance—it is disunity and disobedience.
“Genuflecting as we petition God for the conversion of the Jews is not wrong. Saying that the Holy Catholic Church can mock Christ in her liturgy is.”
“The sovereign pontiff alone enjoys the right to recognize and establish any practice touching the worship of God. No private person has any authority to regulate external practices of this kind...”
“The Catholic Church is built on Peter, the rock, not on scripture or tradition.”
Host
Guest
Father James Maudsley
person
Pope Pius XII
person
Pope Pius IX
person
Dom Prosper Guéranger
person
Matthew 27:27–29
other
Pope Leo XIII
person
Archbishop Guido Pozzo
person
Novus Ordo Watch
organization
Cardinal Francis Spellman
person
Mediator Dei
other
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “TRADCAST EXPRESS 224: Fr. James Mawdsley and the Good Friday Genuflection Controversy” inside PodZeus.
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime