The original clickbait king
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “The original clickbait king” inside PodZeus.
This episode of Throughline explores the origins of modern sensational journalism through the story of William Randolph Hearst and the dramatic rescue of Cuban revolutionary Evangelina Cisneros in 1897. Hearst, a young newspaper magnate, transformed American journalism by turning it into an active, participatory force—what he called 'journalism that acts.' His New York Journal used bold headlines, vivid storytelling, and even orchestrated real-life rescues to capture public attention. The most famous example was the jailbreak of Cisneros, a teenage political prisoner, which Hearst’s reporters executed with theatrical flair, framing it as a medieval romance where the newspaper itself was the hero. While celebrated at the time as a triumph of journalistic activism, the episode examines the long-term consequences: the erosion of trust in media, the blurring of fact and fiction, and the rise of partisan, emotionally charged narratives that continue to shape today’s news landscape. The story also contrasts Hearst’s interventionist model with the more detached, 'objective' approach championed by The New York Times, whose 'all the news that's fit to print' ethos emerged as a reaction to yellow journalism’s excesses.
Hearst pioneered 'journalism that acts'—where news organizations don’t just report events but actively intervene to solve them.
The rescue of Evangelina Cisneros was a manufactured narrative that blended fact, fiction, and spectacle to fuel public engagement.
Yellow journalism, while popular, eroded trust in media by prioritizing drama over accuracy, a trend that echoes in today’s digital media environment.
The rise of partisan media and the decline of shared reality are rooted in historical shifts in how news is constructed and consumed.
Modern newsrooms face a crisis of purpose: should they inform, entertain, or act? The answer may lie in balancing truth with narrative power.
The Prism of Politics and the Birth of Action Journalism
The episode opens with a reflection on how political identity now shapes all aspects of life, setting the stage for a deep dive into William Randolph Hearst’s revolutionary approach to journalism. His belief that newspapers should act, not just report, is introduced through the dramatic rescue of Evangelina Cisneros.
From San Francisco to New York: The Rise of the Sensational Press
Hearst’s early career is traced through the San Francisco Examiner’s dramatic rescue of a drowning fisherman, which established his model of heroic journalism. His move to New York and competition with Joseph Pulitzer ignited the era of yellow journalism.
The Murder Squad and the Myth of the Newsroom Hero
Hearst’s 'murder squad' in New York exemplifies his belief in participatory journalism. By solving crimes ahead of police, the Journal positioned itself as a savior of the public, blurring the line between reporting and intervention.
Jailbreak Journalism: The Cisneros Rescue as National Spectacle
“I had many fantastic dreams in my prison, but I never dreamed of liberty coming to me from an American newspaper.”
The Legacy of Action Journalism: Triumph and Backlash
“Think of the brainless folly of the act. It might upset all negotiations and make the efforts of the president to win independence for Cuba by peaceful means absolutely useless.”
“I worry that the American public no longer cares as much if something is made up or if there's a level of fabrication or stretching of the facts, provided the narrative fits their social and political biases.”
“We will be the journalism that acts.”
“Think of the brainless folly of the act. It might upset all negotiations and make the efforts of the president to win independence for Cuba by peaceful means absolutely useless.”
Host
Guests
William Randolph Hearst
person
New York Journal
organization
Evangelina Cisneros
person
The New York Times
organization
Carl Decker
person
Joseph Pulitzer
person
San Francisco Examiner
organization
Casa de Recojidas
organization
President McKinley
person
Yellow Kid
media
What the banana tells us about US history
Throughline • 14m • 3/31/2026
Al Capone and the transformation of the IRS
Throughline • 51m • 4/2/2026
Who gets to be an American citizen?
Throughline • 15m • 4/7/2026
Will AI destroy us... or save us?
Throughline • 51m • 4/9/2026
How the US became America
Throughline • 15m • 4/14/2026
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “The original clickbait king” inside PodZeus.
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime
