212: The Other Man
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “212: The Other Man” inside PodZeus.
This American Life's rerun episode 'The Other Man' explores the profound disruptions caused by outsiders who enter intimate family systems, altering relationships, identities, and dynamics. The first story follows Davey Rothbart’s family, where his mother, after becoming deaf, began channeling an ancient Buddhist spirit named Aaron. Though initially skeptical, Davey comes to see Aaron as a transformative force—helping heal his parents’ fractured marriage and providing spiritual guidance to thousands. The second act centers on Congressman Jesse L. Jackson Jr., who faces a political nightmare when a rival named Jesse L. Jackson (a retired truck driver) appears on the ballot, orchestrated by political enemies. The race becomes a media circus, exposing deep-seated resentment and electoral manipulation. The final story, 'Mr. Fun,' recounts Jonathan Goldstein’s awkward courtship with Heather O'Neill, whose young daughter Arizona resists his presence. Through a series of humorous, poignant, and heartbreaking moments, the episode reveals how a new person can upend a family’s equilibrium—sometimes for better, often for worse. At its core, the episode asks: what happens when the familiar orbit of a family is disrupted by an 'other man'—real or imagined?
The arrival of an outsider—whether a spirit, a political rival, or a new romantic partner—can fundamentally shift family dynamics and relationships.
Belief in something intangible (like a spirit or a political identity) can be more powerful than proof, especially when it brings healing and purpose.
Children often act as truth-tellers, exposing emotional truths adults try to hide—like Arizona’s blunt verdict that her mother’s new partner 'isn’t fun.'
Political sabotage can take absurd forms, but when done with precision, it can have serious consequences—especially when it exploits shared names and public perception.
Love and acceptance in relationships often require patience, humility, and the willingness to be seen as 'the other'—even when you’re trying your best.
The Star Who Upended the Family
Sarah recounts how Robert Redford’s unexpected visit to her childhood home in Long Island disrupted her family’s dynamic. As the only movie star ever to stay, Redford’s presence shifted the family’s gravity, making Sarah feel like she’d lost her status as the center of attention. Her jealousy and subtle acts of defiance—like rocking the bench—highlight how a single outsider can alter a child’s sense of self.
The Psychic Buddha: Aaron’s Arrival
“I think believing in Aaron is a lot like believing in God. I have a hard time having an unswerving faith in something you can't see or prove exists. But I do have that kind of faith in my mom. That's why I believe in Aaron.”
The Jackson Two: A Name That Divides
“The only we got in public office is through his daddy's name. But this other Jackson have had the name long before.”
Mr. Fun: The Child Who Saw the Truth
“This isn't what you'd do to have a good time. It was like she had summoned up every little bit of maturity she had, and some she didn't even have.”
“Why did I ever marry you? All the way home, the question just sat there, big and awkward, like the watermelon on my lap that we would have for dessert that night.”
“This isn't what you'd do to have a good time. It was like she had summoned up every little bit of maturity she had, and some she didn't even have.”
“I think believing in Aaron is a lot like believing in God. I have a hard time having an unswerving faith in something you can't see or prove exists. But I do have that kind of faith in my mom. That's why I believe in Aaron.”
Host
Guests
Aaron
other
Davey Rothbart
person
Arizona O'Neill
person
Jonathan Goldstein
person
Jesse L. Jackson Jr.
person
Heather O'Neill
person
Mark Brown
person
Sarah
person
Robert Shaw
person
William Shaw
person
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “212: The Other Man” inside PodZeus.
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime