Not Monsters. Not Madmen. Just Men.
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Not Monsters. Not Madmen. Just Men.” inside PodZeus.
In this compelling episode of The Michael Shermer Show, host Michael Shermer interviews author Jack Elhye about his book The Nazi and the Psychiatrist, which inspired the 2026 film Nuremberg starring Russell Crowe. The discussion centers on Dr. Douglas M. Kelly, a U.S. military psychiatrist who, during the first Nuremberg trial, assessed 22 high-ranking Nazi defendants—including Hermann Göring—using psychological tools like the Rorschach inkblot test. Kelly’s groundbreaking conclusion: these men were not madmen or monsters, but intelligent, calculating, and normal in personality—driven by a lust for power and manipulation. This revelation challenged the prevailing notion that evil leaders must be psychologically ill, instead pointing to authoritarianism as a human trait present across societies. The episode explores the psychological mechanisms behind obedience, propaganda, and moral disengagement, drawing parallels to modern political dynamics and the enduring danger of charismatic authoritarian figures. Elhye also reflects on Kelly’s tragic postwar life, his failed efforts to reform democracy through education and voting access, and his eventual suicide—mirroring Göring’s cyanide death in a symbolic act of defiance. The conversation underscores that evil is not born in madness, but in the banality of ambition and the failure of systems to hold power accountable.
The Nazis were not mentally ill—Dr. Kelly found them psychologically normal, which makes their crimes more terrifying and human.
Power, not ideology, was the primary motivator for most Nazi leaders; they were opportunists who exploited the system.
The Rorschach test revealed deep psychological projections, but it was not a diagnostic tool for mental illness—its use in Nuremberg was more about insight than pathology.
Kelly’s conclusion—that evil stems from authoritarian personalities, not psychosis—challenges the 'madmen' narrative and shifts focus to social and political psychology.
The Nuremberg trials were a landmark in establishing crimes against humanity and setting a precedent for international justice.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
The Psychology of Power: Not Monsters, But Men
“It is a weakness not to be able to stand the sight of dead people. The best way of overcoming it is to do it more often than it becomes a habit. That's how to turn your population into killers.”
Dr. Kelly’s Mission: Assessing the Unthinkable
Elhye recounts how Kelly, a brilliant but unconventional psychiatrist, was given rare access to the Nazi defendants. He conducted psychological evaluations using Rorschach tests, IQ assessments, and deep interviews, ultimately concluding that these men were not psychiatrically ill—just power-hungry, manipulative, and normal.
Göring: The Charismatic Monster
“He was also a quite formidable guy, highly intelligent and manipulative. And these men, these two guys duked it out in Göring's prison cell in their long conversations, manipulating one another...”
The Banality of Evil: Not Madness, But Choice
“If you don't regard them as monsters, if you don't regard them as madmen, that makes them responsible for their choices and you can hold them to account. That's a comforting thought to me.”
The Nuremberg Trials and the Birth of International Justice
The episode examines the historical significance of the Nuremberg trials as the first attempt to hold leaders accountable for crimes against humanity. The screening of concentration camp footage shocked both defendants and the public, proving the scale of the Holocaust and setting a precedent for future tribunals.
“They were not madmen. They were not monsters. They were similar to people we always have around us.”
“If you don't regard them as monsters, if you don't regard them as madmen, that makes them responsible for their choices and you can hold them to account. That's a comforting thought to me.”
“This isn't something German, it's reflective of humankind, that there are going to be people like this arising all the time.”
Host
Guest
Douglas M. Kelly
person
Hermann Göring
person
Jack Elhye
person
Nuremberg Trials
other
Rorschach test
product
Michael Shermer
person
David Irving
person
Milgram experiments
other
Stanford Prison Experiment
other
Adolf Eichmann
person
The Psychology of Gaslighting, Bullying, Cults, and Coercion
The Michael Shermer Show • 1h 17m • 3/31/2026
Debra Soh on Why Men and Women Are Drifting Apart, Dating Apps, and Gen Z
The Michael Shermer Show • 1h 30m • 4/3/2026
Shermer Says 8: Easter Without the Miracle
The Michael Shermer Show • 19m • 4/5/2026
What Turns Sand Into Cells? How Nonliving Matter Becomes Alive
The Michael Shermer Show • 1h 27m • 4/8/2026
How Christianity Made America—and How America Remade Christianity
The Michael Shermer Show • 1h 31m • 4/11/2026
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Not Monsters. Not Madmen. Just Men.” inside PodZeus.
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime