THE HERD - Hour 3 - Jeff Passan joins the show, this weeks polls

The Herd with Colin Cowherd42mMay 8, 2026

Get the full intelligence

Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “THE HERD - Hour 3 - Jeff Passan joins the show, this weeks polls” inside PodZeus.

AI-Generated Summary

In this third hour of The Herd with Colin Cowherd, Jeff Passan joins the show as a guest, bringing his signature blend of sports insight and self-deprecating humor. The conversation dives deep into the New York Yankees' pitching resurgence, with Passan praising Cam Schlittler's breakout performance while acknowledging Paul Skeens' elite status, though ultimately siding with keeping Schlittler. The panel debates whether Derek Jeter would have been the same player outside of New York, emphasizing the importance of franchise context. They also discuss the evolving culture of baseball, celebrating dugout celebrations as a much-needed infusion of fun. A recurring theme is the role of AI in sports analysis, with hosts expressing skepticism about its reliability despite its convenience. The hour concludes with a lively 'One Table' game, where guests debate who deserves a coveted seat at a restaurant among baseball legends, culminating in a spirited debate over Pete Rose, Sandy Koufax, and Aaron Judge. The episode wraps with a series of audience polls on topics ranging from celebrity appeal to dental tricks and the importance of Game 2 in a series.

Key Takeaways
1

Cam Schlittler's rise as a Yankees ace makes him a more valuable asset than trading for Paul Skeens, despite Skeens' Cy Young form.

2

Franchise context matters—Derek Jeter's greatness was amplified by the New York Yankees' spotlight and pressure.

3

Baseball's dugout celebrations add much-needed entertainment and personality to the game.

4

AI tools, while helpful, are prone to errors and should not replace human judgment in sports analysis.

5

The 'One Table' game highlights how legacy and charisma influence perceptions of greatness beyond pure stats.

Chapters
0:00
5 min

Sponsor Breaks and Intro

The episode opens with multiple podcast sponsor ads for Humor Me, Superhuman, Stuff to Blow Your Mind, Look Back At It, and Learn the Hard Way, promoting comedy, sports, and mental health content.

5:00
5 min

Jeff Passan Joins the Show

Jeff Passan, a Syracuse University alumnus, joins the show. The hosts tease him about his past and his financial contributions to the school, while Passan jokes about his daughter's enrollment and the cost of college.

10:00
10 min

Cam Schlittler vs. Paul Skeens Debate

He doesn't even know what to do with that.

Highlight
20:00
10 min

Derek Jeter and Franchise Impact

I think he would probably say that too.

Highlight
30:00
10 min

The Role of AI in Sports Analysis

I'm not on Jeff Passan's side on this. I am. Jeff is on his own on this one.

Highlight
High-Impact Quotes
I would see Sandy Koufax over God himself.
Jeff Passan27:09
Viral: 90.0
The Dodgers aren't bad for baseball. They're gasoline on the fire.
A.I. Colin20:17
Viral: 88.0
He doesn't even know what to do with that.
Colin Cowherd17:54
Viral: 85.0
Speakers

Hosts

Colin CowherdTaylor TwellmanStu Gatz

Guest

Jeff Passan
Topics Discussed
Yankees Pitching Development90%Franchise Impact on Player Legacy85%AI in Sports Commentary80%Baseball Dugout Culture75%Sports Media Fumbles70%Audience Polls and Fan Culture65%College and Professional Sports60%Sports Journalism Ethics55%
People & Brands

The Herd with Colin Cowherd

media

15xPositive

Jeff Passan

person

12xPositive

Colin Cowherd

person

10xPositive

New York Yankees

other

10xPositive

Cam Schlittler

person

8xPositive

A.I. Colin

other

8xNeutral

Derek Jeter

person

7xPositive

Paul Skeens

person

6xPositive

Syracuse University

organization

5xPositive

Bill Simmons

person

5xMixed

Get the full intelligence

Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “THE HERD - Hour 3 - Jeff Passan joins the show, this weeks polls” inside PodZeus.

Start discovering podcast insights today

Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.

No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime