THE HERD - Hour 1 - NFL Draft day, thoughts on Fernando Mendoza

The Herd with Colin Cowherd43mApril 23, 2026

Get the full intelligence

Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “THE HERD - Hour 1 - NFL Draft day, thoughts on Fernando Mendoza” inside PodZeus.

AI-Generated Summary

Colin Cowherd kicks off NFL Draft day with high energy and deep analysis, focusing heavily on quarterback Fernando Mendoza as the top prospect. He passionately defends Mendoza against critics who compare him unfavorably to NFL legends like Matt Ryan, arguing that such comparisons are outdated and unfair. Cowherd emphasizes that Mendoza belongs in the same class as the last 17 first-round quarterbacks, with only Caleb Williams and Drake May ranking above him. He presents a detailed mock draft for the first 15 picks, highlighting strategic selections like Mendoza to the Raiders, Caleb Downs to the Ravens, and Sonny Stiles to the Cowboys. Cowherd also debates the balance between need and best player available, arguing that in a weak draft, teams should prioritize talent over position scarcity. He expresses excitement for the Miami Dolphins and New York Giants drafts, noting the potential for transformative picks. The episode concludes with a shift to NBA playoff analysis, where Cowherd praises LeBron James' age-defying performance and questions the value of other stars like Luka and Wemby due to injury concerns.

Key Takeaways
1

Fernando Mendoza is the safest first-round pick and should be ranked among the top 17 first-round quarterbacks in the past five years.

2

In a weak draft, teams should prioritize 'best player available' over positional need, especially when only three elite players exist.

3

LeBron James at 41 is the most productive and available playoff performer, outperforming younger stars due to consistency and durability.

4

The Rams and Vikings are strong candidates to draft Ty Simpson due to quarterback needs and team context, despite not being a top-tier pick.

5

Teams with strong rosters (like Minnesota) can still be undermined by poor quarterback play, proving that talent alone isn’t enough.

Chapters
0:00
4 min

Draft Day Kickoff & Sponsor Segments

The episode opens with multiple iHeartMedia podcast promotions, including 'Dos Amigos', 'Sino Show', 'Nick Dick and Paul Show', 'Math & Magic', and others, followed by a brief intro to The Herd with Colin Cowherd.

4:00
13 min

Fernando Mendoza: The Safe First Pick

Find me the NFL highlights that look like that. So you keep telling me, but he's not very athletic. You told me that about Justin Herbert. You told me that about CJ Stroud. I keep hearing, I've said, I see more poor man's Andrew Luck. He's not Andrew Luck. But you keep telling me it's Matt Ryan. I'm showing your runs. Find me the one NFL career run that Matt Ryan, look at this. That's not Matt Ryan.

Highlight
17:00
17 min

Mock Draft: First 15 Picks & Strategic Picks

I think the Rams, I like that idea of Freeling, the offensive lineman, but I don't think they pass on Makai Lemon. There's been a lot of smoke around him as another receiver, especially given the Puka stuff and trying to trade Devontae.

Highlight
34:00
10 min

Need vs. Best Player Available Debate

In a draft where Caleb Downs at safety is Kyle Hamilton was in a draft that was a really good draft. Okay? This is not that. So I think what you look at if you're the Giants, because the Giants, my argument is they don't have as many needs as you think.

Highlight
44:00
12 min

NBA Playoff Analysis: LeBron’s Legacy

LeBron at 41 years old in the NBA. I would say Jokic 1, SGA 2, Ant 3, Jalen Brown 4. Well, what about Wemby? Plays fewer minutes. May not be available tonight. First couple years. Wemby, we all kind of ask the same question. If he doesn't get hurt, he'll be... I never asked that with LeBron.

Highlight
High-Impact Quotes
Find me the NFL highlights that look like that. So you keep telling me, but he's not very athletic. You told me that about Justin Herbert. You told me that about CJ Stroud. I keep hearing, I've said, I see more poor man's Andrew Luck. He's not Andrew Luck. But you keep telling me it's Matt Ryan. I'm showing your runs. Find me the one NFL career run that Matt Ryan, look at this. That's not Matt Ryan.
Colin Cowherd24:37
Viral: 92.0
LeBron at 41 years old in the NBA. I would say Jokic 1, SGA 2, Ant 3, Jalen Brown 4. Well, what about Wemby? Plays fewer minutes. May not be available tonight. First couple years. Wemby, we all kind of ask the same question. If he doesn't get hurt, he'll be... I never asked that with LeBron.
Colin Cowherd35:04
Viral: 88.0
In a draft where Caleb Downs at safety is Kyle Hamilton was in a draft that was a really good draft. Okay? This is not that. So I think what you look at if you're the Giants, because the Giants, my argument is they don't have as many needs as you think.
Colin Cowherd49:09
Viral: 85.0
Speakers

Host

Colin Cowherd
Topics Discussed
NFL Draft Analysis95%Fernando Mendoza Prospect Evaluation90%Best Player Available vs. Need88%Quarterback Comparisons85%NBA Playoffs Performance80%Team Building Strategy75%Injury Risk in Sports70%Financial Literacy60%
People & Brands

Fernando Mendoza

person

25xPositive

Caleb Downs

person

18xPositive

Colin Cowherd

person

15xPositive

LeBron James

person

15xPositive

New York Giants

organization

12xPositive

Jeremiah Love

person

12xPositive

Ty Simpson

person

10xNeutral

Rams

organization

10xNeutral

Los Angeles Rams

organization

10xNeutral

Minnesota Vikings

organization

8xPositive

Get the full intelligence

Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “THE HERD - Hour 1 - NFL Draft day, thoughts on Fernando Mendoza” inside PodZeus.

Start discovering podcast insights today

Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.

No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime