THE HERD - Hour 1 - Aaron Rodgers is close to coming back, Joel Embiid continues to make us scratch our heads

The Herd with Colin Cowherd opens with a deep dive into the potential return of Aaron Rodgers to the NFL, specifically his expected signing with the Pittsburgh Steelers. Cowherd argues that Rodgers deserves a significant contract after a standout 2024 season, calling the Steelers' quarterback management a long-term failure compared to other franchises that plan for the future. He criticizes the Steelers for treating quarterback like a replaceable position, contrasting them with teams like the Eagles, Rams, and Packers who have structured quarterback development. The discussion then shifts to Joel Embiid’s ongoing injury issues with the Philadelphia 76ers. Cowherd highlights that the team performs better without Embiid, citing improved net rating and offensive pace, and suggests it’s time to move on from his massive cap hit. He frames Embiid as a 'fun uncle'—entertaining when present but unreliable. The episode also covers the Warriors’ decline, with Cowherd arguing they’ve lost their dynasty edge and are clinging to outdated success. He draws a parallel to the Vegas gambling analogy, warning that dynasties must know when to walk away. Other topics include the NBA draft’s imbalance, tanking concerns, and the impact of coaching and systems on quarterback performance, using Kyler Murray and Sam Darnold as case studies. The episode closes with reflections on team continuity, player dependency, and the emotional toll of relying on star players who are often injured. Key takeaways include: 1) The Steelers must treat quarterback as a long-term strategic position, not a stopgap. 2) Joel Embiid’s injury-prone nature makes him a risky long-term investment, and the Sixers should consider a rebuild. 3) Dynasties like the Warriors must accept when their window has closed and not cling to past glory. 4) Quarterback success is heavily dependent on coaching, system, and team culture, not just talent. 5) The NBA’s draft imbalance creates a 'circumstantial tanking' year, but the real issue is player health and load management. 6) Teams should prioritize continuity and reliability over star power when building championship contenders. 7) Coaches and front offices must be honest about player limitations and avoid over-reliance on one superstar. 8) The best teams are built around sustainable systems, not just individual brilliance.