Colin Cowherd Podcast - NFL Draft Reaction: Rams-Ty Simpson, Cowboys-Caleb Downs, Giants & Jets Smart

The Herd with Colin Cowherd1h 34mApril 24, 2026

Get the full intelligence

Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Colin Cowherd Podcast - NFL Draft Reaction: Rams-Ty Simpson, Cowboys-Caleb Downs, Giants & Jets Smart” inside PodZeus.

AI-Generated Summary

Colin Cowherd and his co-hosts deliver a dynamic, in-depth analysis of the 2026 NFL Draft across three segments, dissecting first-round picks and late-round moves with sharp, often contrarian insights. The Rams’ selection of quarterback Ty Simpson at 13th overall sparks debate, framed as a high-risk, long-term developmental gamble rather than a short-term fix, especially given their quarterback depth. In contrast, the Cowboys’ pick of safety Caleb Downs at 11th is hailed as a blueprint for building a versatile, high-upside defense. The Giants and Jets are praised for their value-driven, need-based selections—Arvel Reese and Kenyon Sadiq, respectively—highlighting a strategic shift away from chasing immediate star power. The episode also explores broader trends in college football, including the Big Ten’s financial ascendancy over the SEC due to massive media deals and endowments, the leveling effect of NIL on recruiting, and the rise of elite talent from smaller schools. Cowherd emphasizes the importance of culture, coaching stability, and long-term development, especially as teams like the Patriots, Chiefs, and Jets make calculated moves to rebuild their defensive units. Late-round picks, such as Notre Dame’s Jadarian Price, are celebrated for their explosive potential and return skills, particularly in a weak running back class. The draft’s overall landscape is marked by the Big Ten’s dominance with 10 first-round picks—the first time since 2015 the SEC didn’t lead—signaling a seismic shift in college football power dynamics.

Key Takeaways
1

The Rams' selection of Ty Simpson is a high-risk, long-term developmental play, not a short-term solution for quarterback needs.

2

Caleb Downs’ pick by the Cowboys exemplifies a smart, value-driven strategy to build a versatile defensive core.

3

The Giants and Jets made impactful, need-based picks that prioritize long-term team culture and development over immediate star power.

4

The Big Ten has overtaken the SEC in first-round dominance due to superior financial resources and media deals, reshaping college football’s power structure.

5

NIL has empowered smaller schools to compete for top talent, especially at skill positions, fostering loyalty and underdog motivation.

…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus

Chapters
0:00
20 min

Rams' Ty Simpson Pick: Risky Long-Term Play or Reckless Gamble?

You're not getting any reps, Colin. I think you are getting reps with Stafford. I think Stafford last year... First of all, you're getting every snap in the preseason.

Highlight
20:00
20 min

Cowboys' Caleb Downs: A Defensive Masterstroke

I've never been around a guy that young that I felt like this guy should probably be in the NFL now.

Highlight
40:00
30 min

Giants & Jets: Value Picks That Build for the Future

I don't think anybody's surprised by Mendoza to the Raiders, Bailey to the Jets, Jeremiah Love, the Cardinals, Carnell Tate to Tennessee.

Highlight
1:10:00
18 min

College Football’s Financial Shift: Big Ten vs. SEC

The episode transitions into a broader analysis of college football’s evolving financial landscape. Cowherd argues that the Big Ten is pulling ahead of the SEC due to massive endowments, media deals, and the ability to attract top-tier talent through financial incentives. He discusses how NIL has empowered smaller schools like Indiana and Vanderbilt, and how the financial gap is now more about 'making more' than 'caring more'. The chapter ends with a prediction that college football will eventually consolidate into two dominant super-conferences.

1:23:36
2 min

Jets' Draft Strategy: Omar Cooper & Kenyon Sadiq

The Jets got the best edge rusher, a universally respected wide receiver. And again, Kenyon Sadiqson, he's just – It's a riskier pick. He's kind of can be a little hit or miss.

Highlight
High-Impact Quotes
I've never been around a guy that young that I felt like this guy should probably be in the NFL now.
Colin Cowherd13:20
Viral: 90.0
The Big Ten is we just make more. And that's the difference. Players were always getting paid, now it's above board.
Colin Cowherd67:46
Viral: 88.0
You're not getting any reps, Colin. I think you are getting reps with Stafford. I think Stafford last year... First of all, you're getting every snap in the preseason.
Colin Cowherd8:37
Viral: 85.0
Speakers

Host

Colin Cowherd
Topics Discussed
NFL Draft Strategy95%College Football Financials92%NFL Draft Analysis90%Quarterback Development88%Running Back Draft Class85%Coaching Stability and Team Culture80%Small School Player Evaluation75%Podcast Promotions70%
People & Brands

Colin Cowherd

person

15xNeutral

Los Angeles Rams

other

14xNeutral

Ty Simpson

person

12xMixed

Dallas Cowboys

other

12xPositive

Caleb Downs

person

10xPositive

Big Ten

other

10xPositive

Omar Cooper

person

8xPositive

New England Patriots

organization

7xNeutral

Kansas City Chiefs

organization

6xPositive

Kenyon Sadiq

person

6xMixed

Get the full intelligence

Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Colin Cowherd Podcast - NFL Draft Reaction: Rams-Ty Simpson, Cowboys-Caleb Downs, Giants & Jets Smart” inside PodZeus.

Start discovering podcast insights today

Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.

No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime