3 & Out - NFL Post Draft Reaction: Steelers botch Makai Lemon pick, Rams overdraft Ty Simpson, bad draft for 49ers?

In this episode of 'The Herd with Colin Cowherd,' host John Middlecoff delivers a scathing post-draft analysis of the 2026 NFL Draft, focusing on three major missteps: the Pittsburgh Steelers' failure to draft Makai Lemon after signaling intent, the Rams' high-profile selection of Ty Simpson at 13th overall, and the 49ers' perceived lackluster draft performance. Middlecoff argues that the Steelers' front office, led by Omar Khan, made a catastrophic error by being scooped by the Cowboys in a first-round trade, calling it one of the most embarrassing moments in franchise history due to the loss of a top-tier talent and the perceived lack of strategic acumen. He criticizes Khan’s background in salary cap management over player evaluation, comparing the GM role to Apple’s CEO transition—where a product-focused leader is expected to innovate, not just manage money. The Rams’ pick of Simpson is labeled a 'crazy, insane' decision, with Middlecoff emphasizing the immense pressure on a 13th overall quarterback and questioning the value of paying a premium for a player with a 'best-case scenario' of being a mid-tier NFL quarterback. He contrasts this with the Green Bay Packers’ history of avoiding high picks at quarterback unless they’re truly elite. For the 49ers, Middlecoff defends their draft despite criticism, arguing that Kyle Shanahan’s focus on fit and scheme—like blocking and running after the catch—matters more than draft position or consensus picks. He acknowledges the team’s lack of flashy moves but highlights their ability to win games, even if they don’t draft like Howie Roseman. The episode also touches on broader trends: the SEC’s dominance in the draft due to NIL, the rise of tight ends, the transfer portal’s impact on offensive linemen, and the emotional toll of being an undrafted player like Diego Pavia, who is only getting a tryout with the Ravens. Middlecoff concludes with a call for humility, reminding listeners that draft picks are not guaranteed to succeed and that team success ultimately hinges on winning games, not flashy selections.