State of Origin: The Union Way

The Good, The Bad & The Rugby podcast kicks off with a somber tribute to former Scotland international Paul Scott Hastings, whose passing casts a shadow over the episode. But the mood quickly shifts to exhilarating debate as the hosts revive the long-dormant 'State of Origin' concept for English rugby union—reimagining regional rivalries between North, Midlands, South West, and London using current professional players. The episode becomes a spirited fantasy draft, with guests Michael Tindall, Ben Kay, and Martin Johnson passionately arguing over player eligibility based on birthplace, schooling, and family ties. The discussion dives deep into the emotional power of regional identity in rugby, with each selector building dream teams that spark heated debates over players like Owen Farrell, Tom Curry, and Noah Calori. The episode culminates in a full team reveal, bench selections, stadium proposals, and even a coach draft—highlighting how such a tournament could reignite fan passion. Despite acknowledging real-world hurdles like player contracts and club opposition, the hosts believe the emotional and tribal appeal of 'State of Origin: The Union Way' could make it a compelling addition to the rugby calendar. The episode’s most striking insight is that rugby’s future may lie not in more elite competitions, but in rekindling the deep-rooted, community-driven rivalries that once defined the sport.