Grading the 2026 NFL Draft + Winners & Losers

The 2026 NFL Draft has sparked intense debate, and in this episode of *The GM Shuffle*, hosts Jeff Schwartz and Marty Herney dissect the process over process, rejecting traditional draft grades in favor of evaluating team strategy. The Rams’ decision to select Alabama quarterback Ty Simpson at No. 13 becomes the central controversy—was it a bold move for the future or a massive overreach? The hosts argue it was likely a calculated backup quarterback pick, not a starter, driven by Sean McVay’s long-term planning and the need for depth behind Matt Stafford. This sets the stage for a deeper analysis of team processes, with the Eagles, Jets, Cowboys, Browns, Panthers, and Chiefs lauded for smart, value-driven moves. Meanwhile, the Arizona Cardinals’ high-profile selection of running back Jeremiah Love at No. 3 is defended as a strategic offensive balancing act, despite widespread skepticism. The San Francisco 49ers and Atlanta Falcons are labeled 'wait-and-see' due to inconsistent drafting and questionable early picks. The episode culminates in a sobering look at how front offices transition from draft day to minicamp, with the looming reality of Arch Manning’s 2027 first-overall pick already on the horizon.