Women Talking: Advice Columnists in 20th century France with Dr. Sarah Fishman

The French History Podcast47mMay 9, 2026

Get the full intelligence

Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Women Talking: Advice Columnists in 20th century France with Dr. Sarah Fishman” inside PodZeus.

AI-Generated Summary

In this compelling episode of The French History Podcast, host Gary Gerard interviews Dr. Sarah Fishman about her new book, 'Bridges to Feminism: Marcel O'Clerk, Marcel Segal, and Women's Magazines in 20th Century France.' The conversation centers on two pioneering French women advice columnists—Marcel O'Clerk and Marcel Segal—who used their platforms in women's magazines like Marie Claire and Elle to address taboo topics such as abortion, domestic violence, female sexuality, and personal independence during a time of deep social conservatism in France. Despite not identifying as feminists, their empathetic, nonjudgmental columns created a public dialogue that empowered women to think critically about their lives and futures. Fishman draws personal parallels between her own academic journey and the resilience of her subjects, emphasizing how ordinary women’s voices, often overlooked in history, can shape societal change. The episode reveals how these columns laid the intellectual groundwork for the feminist uprisings of the 1960s and 1970s, long before formal movements gained momentum. Fishman reflects on the broader significance of her work: giving voice to marginalized lives, especially those of women navigating war, divorce, trauma, and economic precarity. She highlights how O'Clerk and Segal, both survivors of personal and historical upheaval, used their platforms to advocate for self-reliance, education, and autonomy—messages that resonated across generations. The episode concludes with a touching personal note as Fishman shares her own journey of connecting with descendants of her subjects, underscoring the lasting legacy of these women. Ultimately, the discussion affirms that history is not only made by the powerful but also by those who quietly, courageously, and persistently speak for others.

Key Takeaways
1

Advice columns in 20th-century French women's magazines were powerful tools for social change, addressing taboo topics like abortion and domestic violence before they were publicly discussed.

2

Marcel O'Clerk and Marcel Segal, though not self-identified feminists, helped build a bridge to feminism by promoting women’s independence, self-reliance, and critical thinking.

3

Their columns offered a nonjudgmental, broad-spectrum dialogue that empowered women to question societal norms and plan for lives beyond marriage and motherhood.

4

O'Clerk’s 1961 book, 'The Black Book of Abortion,' published a decade before the 343 Manifesto, was a groundbreaking act of courage that prefigured the abortion rights movement.

5

These columnists’ personal struggles—divorce, loss, war—deepened their empathy and authenticity, making their advice resonate with real-life challenges.

…and 2 more takeaways available in PodZeus

Chapters
0:00
3 min

Sponsor: Prime Video Action Thrillers

Promotion for Prime Video's action-packed films, including 'The Wrecking Crew' and 'The Boys' finale, with a focus on high-octane entertainment.

2:30
3 min

Sponsor: Disorder Show – Prince Andrew & Epstein

Ad for the podcast 'Disorder' featuring insider revelations about Prince Andrew’s ties to Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell.

5:00
5 min

Introduction to Dr. Sarah Fishman and Her New Book

Host Gary Gerard introduces Dr. Sarah Fishman, his former advisor and a leading historian, and previews her new book on two influential French women's advice columnists.

10:00
10 min

Origins and Personal Journeys of O'Clerk and Segal

Fishman details how Marcel O'Clerk, born in Chile, and Marcel Segal, from a Lithuanian Jewish family, each found their way into journalism and advice columns through personal hardship and serendipity.

20:00
10 min

Personal Struggles and Resilience

The hosts explore the profound personal traumas both women endured—domestic violence, loss of children, and divorce—and how these experiences shaped their empathetic, empowering advice.

High-Impact Quotes
She published a book, The Black Book of Abortion, 10 years before the magazine article appeared in 1971 that's said to have started the campaign for women's abortion rights.
Dr. Sarah Fishman25:02
Viral: 90.0
The 1968 upheaval was overdetermined because a lot of the stuff that happens in 68 was not new. Had been going on, these discussions and these dialogues had been going on for decades.
Dr. Sarah Fishman37:42
Viral: 85.0
I'm interested in how ordinary people experience these big historical events... not looking for a single answer about, well, how did they get through it?
Dr. Sarah Fishman43:59
Viral: 78.0
Speakers

Host

Gary Gerard

Guest

Dr. Sarah Fishman
Topics Discussed
Women's Advice Columns in 20th Century France95%Abortion Rights in France92%Feminism and Public Dialogue90%Domestic Violence and Women's Autonomy88%Personal Resilience and Trauma85%Women's Magazines and Mass Media80%Historical Memory and Legacy75%Jewish Identity and Advice-Giving70%
People & Brands

Marcel O'Clerk

person

22xPositive

Marcel Segal

person

20xPositive

Dr. Sarah Fishman

person

15xPositive

Marie Claire

other

12xPositive

Elle

other

8xPositive

Abby and Ann Landers

person

6xPositive

Paris Soir

other

6xNeutral

The Black Book of Abortion

book

5xPositive

Jean Prévost

person

5xNeutral

Simone de Beauvoir

person

4xPositive

Get the full intelligence

Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Women Talking: Advice Columnists in 20th century France with Dr. Sarah Fishman” inside PodZeus.

Start discovering podcast insights today

Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.

No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime