Sam Stein & Will Sommer: Major MAGA Figures Say Trump’s Assassination Attempt Was Staged
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Sam Stein & Will Sommer: Major MAGA Figures Say Trump’s Assassination Attempt Was Staged” inside PodZeus.
Sam Stein and Will Sommer return to The Bulwark for their 'MAGA Mondays' segment, diving into a growing wave of conservative conspiracy theories questioning the authenticity of Donald Trump's 2024 assassination attempt in Butler, Pennsylvania. While initially propagated by liberal 'Blue Anon' circles, the narrative has now been adopted by prominent MAGA figures like Marjorie Taylor Greene, Tucker Carlson, and Joe Kent, who allege the event was staged or covered up by the Biden-led FBI and Secret Service. The hosts unpack the claims, emphasizing the lack of credible evidence and the logistical absurdity of staging such an event—especially involving a known poor marksman like Thomas Matthew Crooks, who was reportedly barred from his high school rifle team. They highlight key facts: Crooks had searched for bomb-making instructions, his parents alerted police before the attack, explosives were found in his car, and a Secret Service agent was recently caught leaking internal documents. The episode also touches on the broader cultural shift, with former MAGA loyalists now using conspiracy theories to express disillusionment with Trump. Despite the emotional weight of the event and the desire for a deeper narrative, the hosts argue that the evidence strongly supports the official account and that the conspiracy theories reflect political frustration more than factual basis.
The idea that Trump staged his own assassination attempt is logistically implausible, especially given the shooter's known poor marksmanship.
Key evidence like Crooks' bomb-making searches, his parents’ warning to police, and the presence of explosives in his car undermines the 'staged' theory.
The shift of conspiracy theories from liberal to conservative circles reflects growing disillusionment with Trump among former MAGA loyalists.
The FBI and bipartisan congressional investigations found no evidence of a cover-up, and the Secret Service followed protocol during the incident.
The timing of the conspiracy resurgence—just days after Biden’s disastrous debate performance—suggests political motivation over factual inquiry.
Welcome Back: Sunburns, Vacations, and the Rise of MAGA Conspiracy Theories
Sam and Will kick off the episode with lighthearted banter about their recent vacations, sunburns, and the challenges of unplugging with young kids. They transition into the central topic: the resurgence of conspiracy theories questioning the authenticity of Trump’s 2024 assassination attempt.
The Shift in Conspiracy Narratives: From Blue Anon to MAGA Skeptics
“It's wild. There was this almost religious element to what had happened. And I remember being at the convention hall... they're talking about Trump in this kind of divine aura around him and God had saved him. And now it's like, well, actually maybe he did, you know, he orchestrated this whole thing.”
Debunking the Staging Theory: Evidence and Logical Inconsistencies
“For it to work, Trump would have had to be so confident in the shooting skills of this would-be assassin that a shot could get close enough to potentially cause him actual damage. And also that the shooter would be willing to sacrifice their life for the president's plot. Frankly, that just seems crazy to me.”
The Role of Media, Social Media, and the Creation of a Conspiracy Universe
The hosts explore how the conspiracy has evolved into a self-sustaining narrative with invented figures like 'Willie Tepez' and viral photos, including a misleading image of Trump’s bleeding ear. They note that the FBI has already addressed many of these claims in a public document.
The Bigger Picture: Disillusionment, Politics, and the Search for Meaning
“This happened like two days after Biden's debate. Okay? Like Trump is ascendant. Like this thing is, he's going to win at this point. Everything is like, wow, my opponent just had the most epic brain fart collapse in the history of politics... You know what we need to do? We need to go through with a plan for that fake assassination time. Doesn't quite make any sense.”
“The idea is you gave you someone went to this 20 year old kid, troubled kid. They're like, this is our guy. I want you to climb up on this thing. You're probably going to die, okay? Because they're going to shoot at you after you shoot at us. But we want you to climb up on this, whatever, this structure, about 300 feet away from the president. We want you to take a shot at him. But we want you to be really precise, okay? We want you to shoot at him and just kind of graze him or near miss him. And you may kill someone in the audience, whatever. It's worth it. But whatever you do, don't hit Trump. Like, just don't do it. Good plan?”
“For it to work, Trump would have had to be so confident in the shooting skills of this would-be assassin that a shot could get close enough to potentially cause him actual damage. And also that the shooter would be willing to sacrifice their life for the president's plot. Frankly, that just seems crazy to me.”
“It's wild. There was this almost religious element to what had happened. And I remember being at the convention hall... they're talking about Trump in this kind of divine aura around him and God had saved him. And now it's like, well, actually maybe he did, you know, he orchestrated this whole thing.”
Hosts
Donald Trump
person
Will Sommer
person
Thomas Matthew Crooks
person
Sam Stein
person
Marjorie Taylor Greene
person
Biden-led FBI
organization
Tucker Carlson
person
Corey Compitore
person
Joe Kent
person
Biden-led Secret Service
organization
Trump & Hegseth Are Increasingly Delusional on Hormuz; TACO Incoming?
The Bulwark • 19m • 3/31/2026
Kristi Noem's Husband Isn’t the Problem
The Bulwark • 36m • 3/31/2026
Reporters Now Need Escorts to Do Their Jobs at the Pentagon (w/ Elliot Williams)
The Bulwark • 22m • 4/1/2026
Possible Ground Troops in Iran, Trump Speech Preview and The Slow-Motion Destruction of NATO | Command Post
The Bulwark • 19m • 4/1/2026
Josh Barro and Paige Cognetti: The World Is Going to Blame Trump
The Bulwark • 10m • 4/1/2026
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Sam Stein & Will Sommer: Major MAGA Figures Say Trump’s Assassination Attempt Was Staged” inside PodZeus.
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime
