Episode 407: Just Say “Uh-Oh”

In Episode 407 of Stick to Wrestling, John McAdam and guests Steve Gennarelli and Jamie Ward deliver a deep, nostalgic, and critically reflective review of WrestleMania II, held on April 7, 1986. The episode opens with a behind-the-scenes anecdote about a missing audio file, leading to a unique format where the hosts analyze pre-recorded promos and match footage from the event. They dissect the show’s uneven quality—highlighting the lack of buildup for many matches, the overuse of celebrities, and the forced nature of several storylines—while also acknowledging moments of genuine entertainment and historical significance. The discussion covers key matches like Hulk Hogan vs. King Kong Bundy in the Big Blue Cage, the controversial Mr. T vs. Roddy Piper boxing match, and the British Bulldogs’ title win over the Dream Team, which marked the end of Dynamite Kid’s career. The hosts also explore the broader context of the WWF’s evolving storytelling, the decline of certain stars like Hercules and Uncle Elmer, and the early signs of Andre the Giant’s heel turn. Throughout, they balance nostalgia with sharp critique, ultimately concluding that while WrestleMania II was a disappointment compared to its predecessor, it served as a crucial learning experience for Vince McMahon, paving the way for the monumental success of WrestleMania III. The episode also features extensive analysis of concurrent WWF programming, including Championship Wrestling and All-Star Wrestling tapings, spotlighting developments like the arrival of the Rougeau Brothers, the rise of Jake the Snake Roberts, and the growing prominence of Paul Roma. The hosts reflect on the business side of wrestling—managerial legacies (Bobby Heenan vs. Paul Heyman), the impact of celebrity casting, and the logistical challenges of touring. They emphasize that while the show lacks the magic of later WrestleManias, its flaws make it a fascinating case study in the maturation of professional wrestling as a major entertainment spectacle. The episode closes with a sense of respect for the era’s ambition, even as the hosts acknowledge its shortcomings.