True Crime Time For April 11, 2026 | Gilgo Beach Killer Pleads Guilty, Insurance Murder Plot, Toy Box Killer Case

This episode of True Crime Time, hosted by Woody Overton on April 11, 2026, delivers a powerful roundup of high-profile criminal cases across the U.S. The episode opens with the historic plea of Rex Hummerman, a 62-year-old architect, who admitted to murdering seven women in the Gilgo Beach serial killings spanning from 1993 to 2010, with the remains scattered across Long Island and the Hamptons. His guilty plea, following years of denial and a complex investigation involving DNA, cell data, and a hidden basement vault of weapons, marks a long-awaited closure for victims’ families. The episode then shifts to a chilling insurance fraud case in North Carolina, where 41-year-old former paramedic Joshua Hunsucker is charged with murdering his wife, Stacey, using toxic eye drops to collect $250,000 in life insurance, while also attempting to stage a kidnapping and poison his daughter. In Alabama, a high-speed, wrong-way interstate chase involving a suspect with 46 prior arrests and four children in the vehicle ends peacefully after spike strips disabled the car, highlighting the dangers of reckless evasion. The episode closes with the disturbing case of David Ray Parker, the so-called 'Toy Box Killer,' a sadistic serial rapist and torturer who built a soundproofed trailer filled with torture devices, confessed to abducting and abusing multiple women, and was sentenced to 224 years in prison before dying in custody. The episode ends with a broader reflection on the persistence of justice, the importance of public tips, and the enduring fight for truth in unresolved cases like Madison’s and Barbara Blunt’s.