5 On It: Should Nico Hoerner be the Cubs' leadoff hitter all the time?

The episode opens with a spirited debate on whether Cubs second baseman Nico Hoerner should be permanently entrenched as the leadoff hitter, with host Leila Rahimi passionately arguing that his career leadoff stats—.285 batting average, .333 OBP, .396 slugging, and a 730 OPS—demonstrate consistent, high-level performance in the top spot. She highlights his speed, approach, and recent success, calling for stability in the lineup. Marshall Harris counters with a nuanced take on the Cubs' pitching rotation, praising Javier Assad’s dominant relief appearance and arguing he’s the most valuable pitcher in the recent series win over the Reds, especially given his uncertain role coming into the season. The conversation shifts to the Bulls’ Patrick Williams, who scored 20 points in a game shortly after the front office that drafted him was fired, sparking a discussion on symbolism and player performance under pressure. The hosts then speculate on the White Sox’s future, predicting a $100 million contract will come in 2028, possibly under new owner Justin Ishbia. Finally, they engage in a lighthearted, detailed mock dinner debate at Circa Resort, dissecting menu items, portioning, and social etiquette when a boss is paying—ranging from lobster bisque to campfire s'mores.