The BIG Carnell Tate Question: Who Helps Cam Ward More?

The episode of Music City Audible dives deep into the central debate surrounding the Tennessee Titans' fourth overall pick in the 2026 NFL Draft: whether to select wide receiver Carnell Tate or running back Jeremiah Love. Hosts Justin Graver and Justin Mello passionately argue both sides, with Mello championing Tate as the clear-cut best receiver in the draft, citing his elite route-running, contested catch rate, and potential to elevate quarterback Cam Ward’s performance. Graver counters that while Tate is a strong pick, Jeremiah Love—despite positional value debates—is the best overall player in the draft and a more impactful long-term asset. The discussion expands into broader NFL draft philosophy, challenging the notion that wide receivers are inherently more valuable than running backs, especially when using EPA (Expected Points Added) as a metric. The hosts critique EPA’s limitations, noting it heavily favors passing plays and fails to account for a running back’s influence on defensive schemes. They also touch on the Titans’ roster needs, the risk of drafting for need, and the importance of long-term player development. Ultimately, both agree Carnell Tate is worth the fourth pick, but Mello insists Love is the superior prospect overall.