Carlos Mendoza Hot Seat, Carson Benge's Weird Swing, Voicemail Episode | 551

In this voicemail-driven episode of Mets'd Up, hosts James and Mark dive deep into the Mets' disastrous start to the 2026 season, fueled by a wave of fan frustration. The conversation centers on the mounting pressure on manager Carlos Mendoza, with multiple listeners calling for his firing after a series of losses and a lack of offensive production. The hosts analyze the team's struggles, highlighting the absence of key players like Juan Soto and the underperformance of new signings, which has left fans disconnected from the roster. They also explore the psychological toll on players, particularly Francisco Lindor, whose positive demeanor during slumps is both praised and scrutinized. A major focus is on the bizarre swing mechanics of Carson Benge, whose data reveals an unprecedented opposite-field attack direction and inefficient bat path, raising concerns about coaching decisions and swing changes. The episode closes with a call for team cohesion, lineup consistency, and a return to proven hitting approaches, including a controversial suggestion to bring back Brett Beatty’s old swing. Despite the negativity, the hosts maintain a tone of cautious hope, emphasizing that the season is far from over.