FAN MOCKS: We Graded Indianapolis Colts Mock Drafts from the Everydayer Club!

Locked On Colts - Daily Podcast On The Indianapolis Colts32mApril 17, 2026

Get the full intelligence

Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “FAN MOCKS: We Graded Indianapolis Colts Mock Drafts from the Everydayer Club!” inside PodZeus.

AI-Generated Summary

In this episode of Locked On Colts, hosts Zach Hicks and Jake Arthur dive into fan-generated mock drafts from the Everydayer Club, evaluating five creative and varied draft scenarios with a focus on realism, value, and alignment with the Colts' historical drafting tendencies. The first mock, from 'Indy to FLA', earns an A-plus for its bold yet plausible picks including TJ Parker, Josiah Trotter, and Deontay Corleone, with the hosts praising its aggressive value strategy. The second, by 'Ulos', receives a B-plus for its authentic, player-centric board featuring Indiana natives and realistic late-round finds like Romello Height and Macau McHale Camara. Jesse’s draft stands out for its bold trades and high-impact picks like CJ Allen and Skyler Bell, earning a B-plus despite reservations about Caden Curry and Emil Wagner. Patrick’s mock, featuring multiple trades and a strong focus on depth, lands at a B, with praise for Chris McClellan and Bryce Betcher but concern over linebacker depth. The final mock, full of trades and a heavy emphasis on running backs and special teams, earns another B, with standout picks like Julian Neal and Aiden Fisher, though it lacks a clear edge rusher. Throughout, the hosts emphasize the unpredictability of the draft and the value of fan insight, while teasing their own final mock drafts for the week ahead.

Key Takeaways
1

Fan mock drafts from the Everydayer Club offer realistic, player-driven strategies that align with the Colts' historical draft tendencies.

2

Trading down and accumulating picks can yield high-value selections, especially in later rounds.

3

Players like TJ Parker, CJ Allen, Skyler Bell, and Chris McClellan are consistently praised as ideal fits for the Colts.

4

The Colts’ need for edge rushers and linebacker depth remains a key theme, with multiple mocks falling short in this area.

5

Late-round picks like Julian Neal, Aiden Fisher, and Luke Altmyer show promise as role players and special teams contributors.

…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus

Chapters
0:00
2 min

Welcome & Everydayer Club Intro

Hosts Zach Hicks and Jake Arthur welcome listeners and introduce the episode’s focus: reviewing fan mock drafts from the Everydayer Club. They promote the club’s benefits, including ad-free episodes and exclusive Discord access.

1:40
4 min

Mock Draft #1: Indy to FLA – A-Plus for Value

If this scenario happens where these players fall, I'd be a huge fan of that. Corleone in round six would be incredible.

Highlight
5:40
5 min

Mock Draft #2: Ulos – B-Plus for Authenticity

I appreciate your conviction. You lost. Yeah, and I think the big thing with that too is like if you told me this is the draft the Colts came away with, it wouldn't shock me in the least bit.

Highlight
10:20
6 min

Mock Draft #3: Jesse – B+ for High-Impact Picks

I love those two players. I might go like eight minus on this draft because I love those two players.

Highlight
15:50
5 min

Mock Draft #4: Patrick – B for Strategic Trades

Patrick’s mock includes multiple trades and a focus on depth. Picks like Chris McClellan and Bryce Betcher are praised, but concerns remain over linebacker depth and Gabe Aukis at 47.

High-Impact Quotes
If this scenario happens where these players fall, I'd be a huge fan of that. Corleone in round six would be incredible.
Zach Hicks4:43
Viral: 85.0
I appreciate your conviction. You lost. Yeah, and I think the big thing with that too is like if you told me this is the draft the Colts came away with, it wouldn't shock me in the least bit.
Jake Arthur7:40
Viral: 80.0
I like how this one comes with conviction and it is that we are going to run the ball here. You got two running backs here to pair with Jonathan Taylor.
Jake Arthur25:41
Viral: 78.0
Speakers

Hosts

Zach HicksJake Arthur
Topics Discussed
Fan Mock Drafts95%Indianapolis Colts Draft Strategy90%Trade Strategy in NFL Draft85%Edge Rusher Needs80%Linebacker Depth80%Running Backs and Special Teams75%Late-Round Value Picks70%Everydayer Club Engagement65%
People & Brands

Jake Arthur

person

38xPositive

Zach Hicks

person

35xPositive

Everydayer Club

organization

22xPositive

Anthony Hill Jr.

person

8xPositive

TJ Parker

person

6xPositive

Vijay Payne

person

5xPositive

Chris McClellan

person

5xPositive

Josiah Trotter

person

4xPositive

Bryce Betcher

person

4xMixed

Romello Height

person

4xPositive

Get the full intelligence

Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “FAN MOCKS: We Graded Indianapolis Colts Mock Drafts from the Everydayer Club!” inside PodZeus.

Start discovering podcast insights today

Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.

No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime