COLTS SQUAD SHOW: Biggest IMPACT Rookie | Which New Colt Will Be a Difference Maker in 2026?

The Locked On Colts Squad Show dives deep into the 2026 NFL Draft, focusing on which rookie will make the biggest impact for the Indianapolis Colts. Host Derek Schultz is joined by analysts Jake Arthur, Zach Hicks, and former NFLer Alan Pinkett to debate the top prospects. CJ Allen, the Colts' second-round linebacker pick, emerges as the consensus favorite for the biggest impact due to his stability, intelligence, and immediate starter potential in Lou Anarumo’s defense. AJ Halsey, the third-round safety, is praised for his playmaking instincts and confidence, though his risk-taking style raises concerns about consistency and injury risk. The panel also discusses worst-case scenarios, emphasizing the danger of injuries derailing the entire class, particularly for key players like Allen and Jalen Farmer, whose depth at offensive line could be crucial. The show then shifts to the 'one that got away' segment, where analysts express regret over missing out on players like Skylar Bell, Kyle Lewis, and Malachi Fields, highlighting positional needs and draft value. Finally, the team reviews national draft grades, noting widespread positive reception—especially for Allen and Halsey—despite some criticism over the lack of a first-round pick and the Sauce Gardner trade. The episode concludes with a nuanced take on the consensus draft board, affirming that while process matters, results will ultimately define the class’s success.