BPA VS. NEED: Which Players Could Indianapolis Colts Draft Despite Not Needing Them?

In this episode of Locked On Colts, hosts Zach Hicks and Jake Arthur dive into a deep dive on draft prospects who don't fit the Colts' most pressing needs—wide receiver, edge rusher, and linebacker—but could still be impactful picks on Day 2 or early Day 3 of the NFL Draft. They explore several high-upside players across different positions, starting with LSU safety AJ Halsey, a versatile, productive four-year starter with elite football IQ and special teams experience, who could thrive in the Colts’ hybrid safety scheme. Next, they highlight Texas A&M guard Chase Basantis, a clean pass protector with elite physicality, and Clemson offensive tackle Blake Miller, a technically sound, four-year starter with elite athleticism and pass protection skills. The conversation shifts to tight end Michael Trigg from Baylor, a fluid route runner with big-play potential and solid blocking, despite inconsistent hands. They also discuss Penn State safety Zaki Wheatley, a high-energy, aggressive player with strong instincts and special teams value, and Oklahoma defensive tackle Grayson Halton, a hyper-productive, explosive SEC player with elite testing numbers and a compelling case despite concerns over arm length. The hosts argue that the Colts could surprise by drafting these players not for immediate need, but for long-term value and fit within their system. The episode concludes with a reminder to join the Everyday Air Club for ad-free content and exclusive access. Key takeaways include: 1) The Colts may prioritize high-upside, versatile players over immediate need; 2) Special teams experience is increasingly critical for roster spots; 3) Players with elite production and intelligence can overcome physical limitations; 4) Drafting for future depth at key positions like defensive tackle is a smart long-term strategy; 5) Technical soundness and experience matter more than raw athleticism in some cases; 6) The Colts’ defensive scheme rewards players who can play multiple roles; 7) High-floor, high-ceiling players like Blake Miller and AJ Halsey are worth considering even if not in need; 8) The draft is as much about fit and potential as it is about need.