CBS Draft analyst JP Acosta’s ‘My Guys’ Best Values + How They Fit The Giants

In this episode of Big Blue Banter, hosts Dan Schneier and Nick Flotto welcome CBS Sports NFL draft analyst JP Acosta to discuss his 'My Guys' list of undervalued 2026 draft prospects, with a focus on potential fits for the New York Giants. Acosta breaks down seven standout players, emphasizing their film tape, athleticism, and positional versatility. Highlights include edge rusher Mason Thomas, safety Tre'von Stooks, linebacker Josiah Trotter, wide receiver Chris Bell, running back Jonah Coleman, offensive lineman Trey Zun, tight end Oscar Delp, cornerback Amari Harvey, defensive tackle Grayson Halton, and guard Kalen Rutledge. The discussion centers on how these players could address Giants' needs—particularly on the defensive line, in the secondary, and at offensive line—despite limited draft capital. Acosta praises players with high motor, situational value, and adaptability, especially those who thrive in gap schemes or as hybrid defenders. The hosts express excitement over Rutledge and Halton as potential tone-setters and fit within Greg Roman’s run-heavy offensive system. The episode concludes with a strong endorsement of CBS Sports’ draft coverage, particularly Pushing the Pile and Acosta’s in-depth analysis. Key takeaways include: 1) Prioritize players with high motor and situational value over pure production; 2) Seek versatile linemen who can play multiple positions and anchor in gap schemes; 3) Target physical, aggressive defenders who thrive in run support and pass rush; 4) Don’t overlook injured prospects with elite athletic traits and proven film; 5) Value players who fit specific schemes like the Giants’ potential gap-based run game; 6) Look beyond traditional measurables—explosiveness and film often tell a better story; 7) Consider late-round steals with high upside and low risk; 8) Trust draft analysts like JP Acosta who combine deep film study with real-world NFL projections.