Mike Rodak: I don’t know if I would spend a first-round pick on Ty Simpson; it’s hard to say if he could be the Browns answer
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Mike Rodak: I don’t know if I would spend a first-round pick on Ty Simpson; it’s hard to say if he could be the Browns answer” inside PodZeus.
Mike Rodak, covering Alabama for 24-7 Sports, joins The Fan's Afternoon Drive to discuss the 2026 NFL Draft, focusing on quarterback Ty Simpson and his potential fit with the Cleveland Browns. Rodak expresses skepticism about drafting Simpson in the first round, citing his limited college starts, inconsistent performance across games, and lack of prototypical physical traits for a top-tier quarterback. While acknowledging Simpson's high football IQ and coach's son pedigree as strengths, Rodak argues that his athleticism is not elite enough to sustain success at the NFL level, and that the pressure of a first-round pick could hinder his development. He suggests the second round—particularly early second—as a more realistic and sustainable landing spot. Rodak also evaluates Caden Proctor, noting his massive physical profile but inconsistency and maturity concerns, making him less of a 'slam dunk' than his size suggests. He praises Jeremy Bernard as a reliable, consistent receiver with strong blocking ability, projecting him as a solid day-two pick. Finally, Rodak weighs in on the future of college football conference championships, predicting they may be eliminated with playoff expansion to 16 or 24 teams by 2027.
Ty Simpson’s high football IQ is his greatest asset, but his athleticism and inconsistency make a first-round pick risky.
Rodak believes Simpson is better suited for a second-round selection to avoid the pressure of being a 'first-round pick'.
Caden Proctor’s physical traits are prototypical for a first-round tackle, but inconsistency and maturity issues hold him back.
Jeremy Bernard is a reliable, durable receiver with strong blocking skills, ideal for a day-two pick.
College football conference championships may be eliminated with playoff expansion to 16 or 24 teams by 2027.
Introducing Mike Rodak and the Ty Simpson Debate
Mike Rodak joins The Fan to discuss Ty Simpson’s potential as a franchise quarterback, setting the stage for a critical evaluation of his NFL draft prospects.
Ty Simpson: Athleticism vs. Consistency
“I don't know if I would spend a first-round pick on him. Just to come out guns blazing here, that's kind of my conclusion.”
The Case for the Second Round
“I think if you are picking in the second, you at least kind of can shed that label of being a first-round pick.”
Caden Proctor and Jeremy Bernard: The Other Draft Targets
“He's more likely a first-round pick than Ty is.”
The Future of College Football Championship Games
Rodak predicts conference championship games may be eliminated with playoff expansion to 16 or 24 teams by 2027, citing lack of drama and risk of injury when both teams are already in the playoff.
“I don't know if I would spend a first-round pick on him. Just to come out guns blazing here, that's kind of my conclusion.”
“I think if you are picking in the second, you at least kind of can shed that label of being a first-round pick.”
“He's more likely a first-round pick than Ty is.”
Host
Guest
Ty Simpson
person
Alabama Crimson Tide
other
Mike Rodak
person
Caden Proctor
person
Cleveland Browns
other
Jeremy Bernard
person
SEC Championship Game
other
The Fan
media
Big Ten
other
Todd McShay
person
Does Todd Monken Already Have a Favorite at Quarterback?
Afternoon Drive on The Fan • 16m • 3/31/2026
Are the Browns Trying To Throw Everyone Off the Scent With QB Competition?
Afternoon Drive on The Fan • 15m • 3/31/2026
Quick Hits: Aaron Rodgers heading back to Pittsburgh?
Afternoon Drive on The Fan • 12m • 3/31/2026
What's more compelling: Shohei Ohtani vs. Guardians or LeBron James vs. Cavaliers
Afternoon Drive on The Fan • 16m • 3/31/2026
Joe DeLeone: Browns can leverage the No. 6 pick if Jeremiyah Love is still available; I’d rather wait until No. 24 to draft a WR
Afternoon Drive on The Fan • 16m • 3/31/2026
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Mike Rodak: I don’t know if I would spend a first-round pick on Ty Simpson; it’s hard to say if he could be the Browns answer” inside PodZeus.
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime
