How would Ty Simpson impact the Browns QB room

The episode of Afternoon Drive on The Fan explores the growing media buzz around Ty Simpson as a potential first-round pick for the Cleveland Browns, particularly at No. 6 overall. Hosts Jonathan Piedl and Jake Volnick express skepticism about the idea, questioning the disconnect between national insiders like Mary Kay and Nick Shook, who are pushing Simpson, and the general fan base, which shows little interest. They debate whether the Browns are using misdirection—possibly to mask a deeper strategy or to create a false narrative around Simpson to justify a later pick. The hosts argue that Simpson doesn’t pass the 'sniff test' at No. 6, especially when compared to more proven prospects like Carnell Tate or Caleb Downs, and that investing first-round capital in a quarterback with such limited college production and development timeline doesn’t make strategic sense. They also highlight the risk of sidelining Shador Sanders, whom they view as a legitimate NFL quarterback, if Simpson is drafted so high. The conversation touches on the precedent of Josh Rosen and the idea of 'taking swings' at quarterback, but the hosts conclude that Simpson’s profile doesn’t align with a logical, high-value pick at that spot. The episode ends with a lighthearted digression on hairlines and a nod to the show’s ongoing mock draft culture.