A Killer Defense
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “A Killer Defense” inside PodZeus.
The 48 Hours episode 'A Killer Defense' examines the 2007 murder trial of Dr. Kirk Turner, a successful dentist accused of killing his wife, Jennifer, in what he claimed was self-defense. After a two-year marriage strained by infidelity and a bitter divorce, Jennifer filed for separation and sued Kirk’s lover, Tonya Colvin, in an alienation of affection lawsuit. On September 12, 2007, Kirk arrived at their horse farm to discuss legal documents, and according to him, Jennifer attacked him with a seven-foot decorative spear. He claims he defended himself with his pocket knife, fatally wounding her. Prosecutors argue this was a staged cover-up: the blood spatter patterns suggest Jennifer was not standing when her throat was cut, and her blood was found beneath Kirk’s fresh blood, indicating he killed her first. Crucially, forensic evidence showed only Kirk’s blood in his pocket, proving he was wounded before defending himself. Despite the prosecution’s narrative, the jury found Kirk not guilty by reason of self-defense after just six hours of deliberation, citing the pocket blood evidence and the credibility of witness Greg Smithson. The verdict shocked the community and deepened the rift between Kirk’s children, Wendy—who believes he’s guilty—and Richie, who stands by his father. The episode explores the emotional toll, the legal battle, and the enduring mystery of truth in a case where perception, trauma, and evidence collide.
The presence of only Kirk’s blood in his pocket proves he was injured before defending himself, a critical piece of evidence in the self-defense claim.
Blood spatter analysis showed Jennifer’s blood was beneath Kirk’s, contradicting his story and suggesting she was already down when killed.
The jury placed high trust in Greg Smithson’s testimony, rejecting the prosecution’s claim of a cover-up despite timeline inconsistencies.
The case highlights how emotional trauma, marital breakdown, and legal strategy can shape a trial’s outcome, even when evidence is contested.
Kirk Turner’s decision to testify in his own defense was a bold gamble that ultimately paid off with an acquittal.
…and 3 more takeaways available in PodZeus
The Setup: A Marriage in Crisis
The episode opens with the aftermath of a high-stakes marital collapse, introducing Jennifer Turner as a devoted wife and horse enthusiast whose life unraveled when her husband, Dr. Kirk Turner, began an affair with their former personal banker, Tonya Colvin. The emotional and financial stakes are high, setting the stage for a volatile confrontation.
The Night of the Attack: A Flash of Violence
“She thrust the spear at him going all the way through then she pulled the spear out and plunged it in again. She launched a vicious and potentially deadly attack on him.”
The Prosecution’s Case: A Staged Self-Defense
“The blood spatter was found on the side of the work table just inches above the floor. Police say that proves Jennifer was not standing when her throat was cut.”
The Defense’s Argument: Blood in the Pocket
“The fact that there was only his blood on that pocket definitively shows that he had suffered all of his wounds before he ever went to defend himself.”
The Witness: Greg Smithson’s Credibility
Greg Smithson, the only eyewitness, testifies that he left Kirk and Jennifer alone in a shed for two to three minutes. He claims he heard Kirk screaming about being attacked and then rushed to help Jennifer. The prosecution questions his timeline and CPR claims, but the defense defends his integrity.
“The fact that there was only his blood on that pocket definitively shows that he had suffered all of his wounds before he ever went to defend himself.”
“She thrust the spear at him going all the way through then she pulled the spear out and plunged it in again. She launched a vicious and potentially deadly attack on him.”
“The jury focused on the blood inside Kirk's jeans. The only blood in his pocket was his blood. He'd already been cut when he went in there to grab the knife.”
Host
Guests
Jennifer Turner
person
Dr. Kirk Turner
person
Greg Smithson
person
Wendy Turner
person
Richie Turner
person
Prosecutor Greg Brown
person
Tonya Colvin
person
Prosecutor Rob Taylor
person
Joe Cheshire
person
Johnny Marks
person
Post Mortem | Denise and Aaron Quinn Get the Last Word
48 Hours • 27m • 3/31/2026
Road to Redemption
48 Hours • 44m • 4/1/2026
The Case Against Brooke Skylar Richardson
48 Hours • 45m • 4/2/2026
The Root Beer Float Murder
48 Hours • 44m • 4/6/2026
Post Mortem | The Root Beer Float Murder
48 Hours • 24m • 4/7/2026
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “A Killer Defense” inside PodZeus.
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime