NFL Draft 1st Round Reaction: Ty Simpson to Rams, Carnell Tate to Titans, Giants & Jets winners?

John Middlekauff delivers a sharp, critical analysis of the 2026 NFL Draft's first round, focusing on the Los Angeles Rams' controversial selection of quarterback Ty Simpson with the 13th overall pick. He expresses disbelief at the move, arguing that Simpson lacks the physical traits and proven production to justify a first-round selection, especially for a team already stacked with talent and in contention for a Super Bowl. Middlekauff questions Sean McVay's enthusiasm, citing his body language during the press conference and his prior pursuit of Kirk Cousins and Jimmy Garoppolo as evidence that McVay may not have been fully on board with the pick. He contrasts this with the Titans' selection of wide receiver Carnell Tate at fourth overall, which he views as a high-risk, high-reward gamble that doesn't align with the elite production expected from a top-five receiver. Middlekauff also praises the Cardinals' decision to take Jeremiah Love, applauding their ability to stay true to their board despite rumors. He explores broader themes of draft economics, the value of position scarcity, and the importance of team culture and long-term planning, using the Giants' and Jets' picks as examples of strategic depth and potential. The episode concludes with a mix of humor and commentary on the chaotic, information-driven nature of the draft process.