Symbolic Liberalism and Dialogical Sociology
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Symbolic Liberalism and Dialogical Sociology” inside PodZeus.
Sari Hanafi, professor of sociology at the American University of Beirut and former president of the International Sociological Association, delivers a compelling 10-minute talk on 'symbolic liberalism'—a phenomenon where individuals espouse classical liberal values like freedom of expression and human rights while acting in ways that are politically illiberal. He critiques how this contradiction exacerbates polarization, undermines dialogue, and deepens social inequalities, particularly in the context of late modernity marked by authoritarianism, economic precarity, and environmental crisis. Drawing from his book *Against Symbolic Liberalism: A Plea for Dialogical Sociology*, Hanafi calls for a 'dialogical turn' in sociology and public life, advocating for a 'dialogical liberal project' that balances individual rights with collective justice, embraces pluralism, and fosters genuine cross-cultural conversation. He illustrates this through case studies, focusing on Sweden’s controversial child protection system, where over 3,000 children were removed from families without consent—highlighting how symbolic liberalism manifests in state overreach, cultural erasure, and the erosion of family as a moral and social institution. Hanafi argues that while some interventions are necessary, the current approach reflects a hegemonic, deculturalized conception of the good that suppresses dialogue and undermines civil society’s foundational institutions.
Symbolic liberalism creates a contradiction between espousing liberal values and acting in illiberal ways, deepening societal polarization.
A dialogical sociology is needed—one that distinguishes between soft normativity (scientific inquiry) and strong normativity (advocacy for marginalized groups).
The Swedish child protection system exemplifies symbolic liberalism: well-intentioned policies have led to mass child removals, reflecting a deculturalized, hegemonic conception of the good.
Family should be seen not as a relic but as a vital institution for moral development, emotional support, and resistance to state and market coercion.
True liberalism requires dialogue, pluralism, and a commitment to coexistence across diverse conceptions of the good, not imposition of one vision.
Introducing Symbolic Liberalism and the Need for Dialogical Sociology
“In an era of deepening polarization, social scientists often reproduce the very injustice they seek to challenge, taking entrenched positions while dismissing alternative perspectives.”
Defining Liberalism and the Problem of Hegemonic Conceptions of the Good
Hanafi distinguishes classical liberalism from Rawlsian political liberalism and critiques how symbolic liberalism distorts justice and universal rights by imposing a single, hegemonic conception of the good.
The Two Levels of Sociology: Soft and Strong Normativity
“I am worried when sociology analytically conflate the two levels or offer no distinction between providing scientific knowledge or scientific thinking and position-taking or policy formulation.”
Case Study: Sweden’s Child Protection System and the Erosion of Family
“The way in which the neoliberal state uses its authority and that of the school or social service over the family's authority, instead of complementing it, is problematic.”
“In an era of deepening polarization, social scientists often reproduce the very injustice they seek to challenge, taking entrenched positions while dismissing alternative perspectives.”
“The way in which the neoliberal state uses its authority and that of the school or social service over the family's authority, instead of complementing it, is problematic.”
“This project also inflates the conception of the universality of human rights and considers only one possible conception of the good, a hegemonic one.”
Host
Sari Hanafi
person
Sweden
place
late modernity
other
John Rawls
person
Against Symbolic Liberalism
book
neoliberalism
other
Universal Declaration of Human Rights
other
Adrian Scribano
person
American University of Beirut
organization
National Board of Health and Welfare
organization
Get the full intelligence
Search transcripts, export clips, track mentions, and explore all topics from “Symbolic Liberalism and Dialogical Sociology” inside PodZeus.
Start discovering podcast insights today
Start with a 7-day trial and explore a growing catalog of popular podcasts. No credit card required.
No credit card required • 7-day trial • Cancel anytime
